Monday, 29 October 2012

A Five Minute Rant for the Consortium of European Research Libraries

I have been asked to participate in a panel at the annual CERL conference - and to speak for no more than five minutes or so.  Initially, I was just going to wing it, but then, in writing up a couple notes, five minutes worth of text found its way on to the screen.  In the spirit of never wasting a grammatical sentence, the text is below.  I probably wont follow it at the conference, but it reflects what I wanted to say.
CERL - British Library, 31 October 2012:
We all know just how transformative the digitisation of the inherited print archive has been.  Between Google Books, ECCO, EEBO, Project Gutenberg, the Burney Collection, the British Library's 19th century newspapers, the Parliamentary Papers, the Old Bailey Online, and on and on, something new has been created.  And it is a testament to twenty years of seriously hard graft.  But, it is one of the great ironies of the minute that the most revolutionary technical change in the history of the human ordering of information since writing - the creation of the infinite archive, with all its disruptive possibilities - has resulted in a markedly conservative and indeed reactionary model of human culture.

For both technical and legal reasons, in the rush to the on line, we have given to the oldest of Western canons a new hyper-availability, and a new authority.  With the exception of the genealogical sites, which themselves reflect the Western bias of their source materials and audience, the most common sort of historical web resource is dedicated to posting the musings of some elite, dead, white, western male - some scientist, or man of letters; or more unusually, some equally elite, dead white woman of letters.  And for legal reasons as much as anything else, it is now much easier to consult the oldest forms of humanities scholarship instead of the more recent and fully engaged varieties.  It is easier to access work from the 1890s, imbued with all the contemporary relevance of the long dead, than it is to use that of the 1990s.  

Without serious intent and political will - a determination to digitise the more difficult forms of the non-canonical, the non-Western, the non-elite and the quotidian - the materials that capture the lives and thoughts of the least powerful in society - we will have inadvertently turned a major area of scholarship, in to a fossilised irrelevance.

And this is all the more important because just at the same moment that we have allowed our cultural inheritance to be sieved and posted in a narrowly canonical form; the siren voices of the information scientists: the Googlers, coders and Culturomics wranglers, have discovered in that body of digitised material, a new object of study.  All digital texts is now data, that date is now available for new forms of analysis, and that data is made up of the stuff we chose to digitise.   All of which embeds a subtle biase towards a particular subset of the human experience.  Using measures derived from Ngrams, and topic modelling, natural language processing, and TF-IDF similarity measures; scientists are beginning to use this text/data as the basis for a new search for mathematically identifiable patterns.  And in the process, the information scientists are beginning to carve out what is being presented as 'natural' patterns of change, that turn the products of human culture into a simple facet of a natural, and scientifically intelligible world.  The only problem with this is that the analysts undertaking this work are not overly worried by the nature of the data they are using.  For most, the sheer volume of text makes its selective character irrelevant.

But if we are not careful, we will see the creation of a new 'naturalisation' of human thought based on the narrowest sample of the oldest of dead white males.  And to this particular audience I just want to suggest that we need to be much more critical about what it is that we digitise; what we allow to represent the cultures libraries and collections stand in for; and that we need to engage more comprehensively and intelligently with the simple fact that we are in the middle of a selective recreation of inherited culture.


Yvonne said...

There is already bias in our physical archives due to past collection decisions. This is further skewed when digitisation programs target those items that are popular or well-known.

In a nutshell: Digitisation should not amplify existing archival bias.

Blogger said...

Did you know you can create short links with AdFly and get $$$ for every visitor to your short urls.

Jonaliya Jonaliya said...

Climadex :- I feel I need to discover amateurs who have same interest in that goal. My stratagem can produce back end profits.
This is how to learn where somebody is working on that. Let's do it by the truck load. That has decreased in recent days. This should be an unlimited version but also I understand that a time consuming process, but this is how using that is done properly. Your detail rapidly became popular in Europe.
Read More==>>

Veronica Segura said...

I blog often and I truly appreciate your information. This great article has really peaked my interest. I am remarkably energetic to investigate this article... Appreciative for giving us experience info. We stumbled over here different page and thought I should check things out. I like what I see so i am just following you. Look forward to looking into your web page again. I'm going to book mark your website and keep checking for your blog. Get redirected to my site Write my Essay

Postdrox said...

Beligra Male Enhancement - In the present current period, the females, as well as influenced by maturing issues.The male's body begins encountering a great deal of changes when the maturing procedure starts.This change incorporates a few changes in men's sexual execution.Men turn out to be explicitly powerless and inert and additionally their ability to keep going for longer in addition to accomplish harder erection denies continuously.In this way, to manage these issues in men, the Beligra Male Enhancement supplement has been planned.This enhancement has the normal and natural male upgrade recipe which invigorates the general continuance of guys and sexual execution.

Gibson Bernice said...

Testo Edge Ex :- Be that as it may, we can't discover the names of its fixings anyplace on the web, as it is a selective web supplement. The greater parts of the fixings are not open before the media and the clients on the grounds that the maker did not wish to get into trick related concerns. This is the motivation behind why they have not uncovered the fixings to people in general. It doesn't imply that they are not sheltered, else unfortunate and shaky. Obviously, they are totally free of fillers or added substances. It doesn't give you any symptoms on your body. It is a flawless supplement for the long run.
Read more==>>

Gibson Bernice said...

Testo Boost X :- Along these lines, in the event that you truly need to uplift your vitality level with a view to perform longer at the exercise center to accomplish your lifting weights objective, and afterward you have to incorporate Testo Boost X, a muscle building dietary supplement in your day by day schedule. It is a fresh out of the plastic new muscle building supplement that guarantees to help you build up a body like your most loved stars by augmenting your workout continuance and decreasing recuperating time.
Read more==>>

Entertaining Game Channel said...

This is Very very nice article. Everyone should read. Thanks for sharing. Don't miss WORLD'S BEST TrainDrivingSimulatorFreeGames

Lucky Patcher said...

whatsapp groups link

luckys said...


Raj Maan said...

lifestyle whatsapp groups

Raj Maan said...

lifestyle whatsapp groups

luckys said...

gta 5 app

Anbarasan14 said...

Thanks for your contribution in sharing such a useful information. Waiting for your further updates.
English Speaking Classes in Mulund West
IELTS Classes in Mulund
German Classes in Mulund
French Classes in Mulund
Best Spoken English Classes in Chennai
IELTS Coaching Centre in Chennai
English Speaking Course in Mumbai
IELTS Coaching in Mumbai
Spoken English Class in T Nagar
IELTS Coaching in Anna Nagar

nnn said...

Nice article
Vidmate YouTube videos downloader

Admin said...

Admin said...

dtc bus app
dtc bus
dtc bus app download
dtc bus pass
dtc bus route
dtc bus route app
dtc bus app download

Admin said...

Download Crunchyroll mod APK