Monday, 6 July 2015

Sources, Empathy and Politics in 'history from below'.



This post was commissioned for inclusion in an online symposium on 'history from below' over at the Many Headed Monster, and is best read in conjunction with the other pieces posted there.  I am reposting it here just by way of keeping track of stuff.  



The purpose and form of history writing has been much debated in recent months; with micro-history, and by extension history from below, being roundly condemned by historians Jo Guldi and David Armitage as the self-serving product of a self-obsessed profession.  For Guldi and Armitage the route to power lies in the writing of grand narrative, designed to inform the debates of modern-day policy makers – big history from above.   Their call to arms – The History Manifestohas met with a mixed reception.  Their use of evidence has been demonstrated to fall short of the highest academic standards, and their attempts to revise that evidence sotto voce has been castigated for its lack of transparency.  

Regardless of the errors made along the way, of more concern to practitioners of ‘history from below’ is Guldi and Armitage’s assumption that in order to influence contemporary debate and policy formation we should abandon beautifully crafted small stories in favour of large narratives that draw the reader through centuries of clashing forces to some ineluctable conclusion about the present.  I have no real argument with the kind of history they advocate – and the success of recent works such as Thomas Piketty’s Capital, suggest that it can both do justice to the evidence, and contribute modern policy debate.  And I am sure with a couple of decades’ hard work (there were 19 years between the publication of the Communist Manifesto, and Das Kapital), Guldi and Armitage will produce a book that lives up to the hype.

But, they fundamentally miss-represent the politics of history writing, and of micro-historical analysis in particular.  And what they seem to miss is a simple appreciation of the shock of the old.  The lessons of history are very seldom about ‘how we got here’ with all its teleological assumptions, but more frequently about how we can think clearly about the present, when we cannot escape from it.  

Understanding classical Greek attitudes to sexuality; Tokugawa Japan’s system of governance, or the use of concentration camps in the Boer War is not about grand narrative, but the interrogation of difference.  What the past has given us is an ‘infinite archive’, reflecting a real – if not fully knowable – world.  By interrogating that archive, we are freed to test our assumptions about the present.  In a scientific mode, we might literally test a theory against the evidence; but just as valid, in a humanist mode we can interrogate a word, a phrase and emotion for its meaning.  In either case, history rapidly becomes a tool to think with – testing and probing the past because it allows us to think about the present more carefully.  

For this purpose, for the purpose of thinking with history, the precise topic of historical analysis is secondary, and ‘grand narrative’ is counterproductive.  In part, grand narrative doesn’t work for this purpose because it is inherently teleological, and brings with it ill-digested assumptions about how human society functions.  One need look no further than the facile accounts of empire found in the work of historians like Niall Fergusson to see the pitfalls; or the risible nationalist diatribes of ‘Historians for Britain’ collective.  If you start with a ‘dog in the fight’ – a defence of American ‘empire’; or an anti-EU agenda - your ability to see clearly is at least compromised.

‘History from below’, by contrast appeals to a very different kind of politics; and it is in essence, a politics of empathy and voice explored through a conversation with the dead.  In the British Marxist tradition, it was founded in the creation of a humanist account of the ‘radical tradition’ that gave to every stockinger and handloom weaver an identity and personality.  The politics of this tradition was found in the demand that the reader empathise with individual men and women caught in a whirl of larger historical changes, and it was, and is, a politics of emotion.  The methodologies of ‘history from below’ use detail and empathy to demand of readers a personal engagement with a specific time and place; just as micro-histories uses the contrast between the everyday and the remarkable, to force the readers’ engagement.

And as a political project, both ‘history from below’ and micro-histories have been remarkably successful.  The public politics of the west in the last fifty years have been dominated by forms of the ‘identity’ politics.   These new politics have helped to push aside the twentieth century’s disastrous obsession with nationalisms (the focus of both older grand narratives, and the crutch leant on by historians such as Fergusson and ‘Historians for Britain’).  

We now have detailed and beautiful histories of the experience of the enslaved, of people excluded by race, gender and sexuality; by dis/ability and poverty.  Each of these ‘histories from below’ have evolved in dialogue with contemporary politics, both feeding the activism of modern campaigns, and perhaps more importantly, ensuring that no-one can be dismissed as less feeling, less human, less important, than anyone else.  By changing the focus of historical writing and research, ‘history from below’ has effectively eroded the inherently racist notion of the ‘volk’ in favour of ‘leuten’; has eroded nationalisms in favour of individual experience.

In other words, history from below has been a remarkably successful form of cultural politics (and Politics), that owes its basic success to the creation of an imaginative and empathetic connection between the individuals, past and present.  But to achieve this end, history from below has made a further contribution to both historical scholarship and methodology that places it at the centre of a wider set of developments.

Despite the (over) reliance of historians such as Edward Thompson on government spy reports, and many social historians’ addiction to parliamentary ‘blue books’; history from below demands that we seek alternative pathways to knowing about individuals – that we seek out readings that work self-consciously against the grain and documents that, however fleetingly, record the experience from below.  And herein lies the problem and the opportunity.  Our sources create a fundamental tension between the bureaucratic character of most inherited documentation reflecting experience from below (endless lists and accounts), and the political work of history from below as a project – to create empathy across time and space.  The conundrum becomes, how do we turn a name, perhaps a number, if you are lucky, a single line – in to a human being.

In part, the answer to this quandary has been found in family and community reconstruction; in the creation of relational databases that pull together fragments of information from as wide a body of sources as can be managed.  When, for instance, small fragments of narrative sieved from pauper letters and examinations, are combined with details of pensions lists and the raw biology available through the International Genealogical Index, we come close to being able to create compelling simulacra of the dead.   A shared experience of childbirth, or hunger; of disability or simple poverty, can be enough to bring to the readers’ minds’ eye a fully formed human being – all the details filled in via the readers’ imagination.   

But even these limited details are unavailable for many.  So we also use strategies of detailed contextualisation.  In part, these strategies mimic the forms of fiction – where small details are used to compress a scene to it tightest compass.  In history from below, we might use location and the built environment as ways of giving authority to an event that would otherwise be dull and off-putting – one of a million settlement examinations; one of five hundred shared beds in a workhouse.  All of which simply gets us to the point where the form and genre of writing history from below comes in to direct conflict with the sources we normally use, creating a tension which in turn explains why ‘history from below’ has been both remarkably productive in the creation of new methodologies; and why, more importantly, it creates a need to rethink and remake the genre of history writing more broadly.

In other words, in the face of challenges from advocates of ‘big history from above’ it seems to me that we are confronted with a series of opportunities, created by the very practise of writing history from below; that in turn provide the basis for a fuller political agenda.  We have an answer to the siren calls of ‘big history’.  And the answer demands just a few things.

First, we need to be much more sophisticated in how we theorise the process of writing and presentation.  There is currently no-one seriously unpacking the literary practise of historical writing from below in a way that would allow us to examine it as an object of study in its own right.  And yet, by being more self-conscious in how we construct emotion and engagement through textual practise, we can raise our game substantially – allowing us to recognise (and teach) the different techniques we use; and to categorise varieties of history writing in new ways.  And while no one would want to see too much self-obsessed naval gazing, there is a real opportunity for substantial criticism that would in turn allow us to present ‘history from below’ as a more fully described set of generic conventions.  Not perhaps a ‘science’, but a clear methodological choice.

Second, we need to embrace innovation more fully, and to identify the digital tools that allow us to construct lives and experience from the distributed leavings of the dead.  The world of early modern and nineteenth century Britain, in particular, are newly available to new forms of connection.  Nominal record linkage, building on a generation of work undertaken by family historians, should allow us to tie up and re-conceptualise the stuff of the dead, as lives available to write about.  Or we can revolutionise close reading of text through a radical contextualisation of words.  By allowing every single word or phrase to be mapped against everything written in the year or decade – we could create a form of close reading that makes for powerful history writing.  Or, we could think about contextualisation more imaginatively, by adding a few more dimensions to the context in which we place our objects of study.  Where is the 3D courtroom and church pulpit; where the soundscape and sound model; where the comprehensive weather data that would allow us to write a life, an event, a moment in new and different detail?

 And finally, my belief is that we need to be more explicit about the political work that we think ‘history from below’ is doing.  If we think the work contributes to a modern political conversation, I think we need to say so – not to simply advocate for our own beliefs, but to use the past to think more carefully about the present.  From my perspective, it does not matter over much if the thinking is about gender, poverty, race or disability; but about ensuring that a conversation with the dead forms a part of our conversation about the present.  

When the likes of Jo Guldi and David Armitage, and the ‘Historians for Britain’ group advocate for big history and the longue durĂ©e, they are making specific claims about how they can intervene in a modern politics; and effectively denigrating other people’s politics along the way.  It is only by countering these claims, and replacing them with our own more subtle analysis that we can do full justice to the aspirations and labours of our colleagues.  There is a coherent intellectual project in ‘history from below’, that perhaps needs more critical inspection, that perhaps needs more technical innovation, but which nevertheless provides the best opportunity we have to create an inclusive, progressive, empathetic history – a way of thinking clearly with the past.     

41 comments:

Unknown said...

Wiztech Automation is a Chennai based one-stop Training Centre/Institute for the Students Looking for Practically Oriented Training in Industrial Automation PLC, SCADA, DCS, HMI, VFD,VLSI, Embedded, and others – IT Software, Web Designing and SEO.

PLC Training in Chennai
Embedded Training in Chennai
VLSI Training in Chennai
DCS Training in Chennai
IT Training Institutes in Chennai
Web Designing Training in Chennai

Unknown said...

The future of software testing is on positive note. It offers huge career prospects for talented professionals to be skilled software testers. Best software testing training institute in Chennai | Software Testing Training in Chennai | Software testing course in Chennai

Unknown said...

Another interesting articles .am amazed i am reading the articles one by one since yesterday night and every time i find a new article grabbing my attention within a post.

SEO Training in Chennai

Anonymous said...

Awesome..You have clearly explained ...Its very useful for me to know about new things..Keep on blogging..
Dotnet training in chennai

Bay Max said...

Great article.It is interesting to read.Keep sharing like this.
Regards,
Software Testing Training in Chennai

Unknown said...

Good information to know and right to the point. Thanks for this well written post, i'll follow up for more updates if you keep posting them.
Regards,
testing training chennai | software testing institutes in Chennai | software testing training institutes

vellore city said...

I like your post. This post really awesome and very helpful to me

remedial teaching for slow learners in chennai | best autism treatment centre in chennai | occupational therapy centre in chennai | special education tuition center in chennai

kanaksoni said...

Who is Giorgio Tsoukalos?

Unknown said...

Awesome Post!
Check out Reason Beind Diya HD pictures
Also download latest movie COMMANDO 2 (2017) DESI PDVD NTSC AC3 EXHD EXCLUSIVE
Also Read trending Story Shocking Snapchat Screenshots
Also Check out Latest vacancy of Government Job Govt. Rajasthan Recruitment 2017

Venkatesh Krishna said...

Thanks for the insightful article from goDigitally

Unknown said...

guide
review
safe
kitchen

Rebecca Virginia said...

Great blog post you shared with us.
Nursing Assignment Help, Nursing Assignment Help.

Unknown said...

thanks for sharing, nice post

Debra Williams said...

You always can publish something top 10 custom essay writing services absorbing that does not waste minutes of your life like what you see on countless other sites. This is very interesting and I will be back for more. Thanks for sharing

rohil said...

Great post and informative blog.it was awesome to read, thanks for sharing this great content to my vision.
Good discussion.
Six Sigma Training in Abu Dhabi
Six Sigma Training in Dammam
Six Sigma Training in Riyadh

Amitabh Bachan said...

Now days people have no time for going to gym and they want to best supplement store in amritsar but they have no idea where they should want to go so our store is available in top 10 bodybuilding supplements store in amritsar, so without any tension please visit our store. we will also provide bodybuilding equipments store in amritsar.

workout session
shoulder exercise
abs workout
9 best food for bodybuilding
best diet for bodybuilding
yoga pose for muscle building
best yoga asana
best food for glowing skin
best way to get rid of acne

Rathinam said...

This blog was very interesting with good guidance, it is very helpful for developing my skill. I eagerly for your more posts, keep sharing...!

Oracle DBA Training in Chennai
Oracle DBA Course in Chennai
Spark Training in Chennai
Oracle Training in Chennai
Linux Training in Chennai
Social Media Marketing Courses in Chennai
Primavera Training in Chennai
Unix Training in Chennai
Power BI Training in Chennai
Tableau Training in Chennai

meldaresearch said...

All our Homework Assignment Help Online are normally written by an expert; therefore, there will never be a time when a student will get poor quality work. We provide students with Assignment Help Service that have been written by experienced writers. Students can count on us to get fast and effective help from writers who hold master’s and Ph.D degrees.

morphigo said...

top 10 apps in india
Best Pirate Bay Alternatives
Free Movie Apps for Android
Free Movie Apps for iPhone

meldaresearchusa said...

Custom Assignment Help online produces different assignments, including Custom Assignment Writing Service, to help students deal with the Legit Essay Writing Servicechallenges they face every day.

svrtechnologies said...

Whatever we gathered information from the blogs, we should implement that in practically then only we can understand that exact thing clearly, but it’s no need to do it, because you have explained the concepts very well on software testing courses online
. It was crystal clear, keep sharing..

kalavani said...

The blog you shared is very good. I expect more information from you like this blog. Thankyou.
Python Training in bangalore
Python Course in Bangalore
Angularjs course Bangalore
Angularjs Training in Bangalore
Web Designing Course in bangalore
Web Development courses in bangalore
Salesforce Course in Bangalore
salesforce training in bangalore
Big Data Training in Bangalore
Hadoop Training in Bangalore

veera said...

Very nice post with awesome content.
thank you.

ios online training

sathya said...

I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon

selenium training in chennai

selenium training in chennai

selenium online training in chennai

selenium training in bangalore

selenium training in hyderabad

selenium training in coimbatore

selenium online training

sathya said...

I must thank you for the efforts you have put in penning this site. I am hoping to check out the same high-grade content by you later on as well. Keep up the good work

selenium training in chennai

selenium training in chennai

selenium online training in chennai

selenium training in bangalore

selenium training in hyderabad

selenium training in coimbatore

selenium online training

lavanya said...

Very interesting to read this article.I would like to thank you for the efforts you had made for writing this awesome article. This article inspired me to read more. keep it up.I am very grateful to read your blog.I hope you would provide the great services in the field of website design and development and Search Engine Optimization. Thank for the share.
Java training in Chennai

Java Online training in Chennai

Java Course in Chennai

Best JAVA Training Institutes in Chennai

Java training in Bangalore

Java training in Hyderabad

Java Training in Coimbatore

Java Training

Java Online Training

surya said...

It was a very wonderful post!!! Thank you for your great work sharing with us.
angular js training in chennai

angular training in chennai

angular js online training in chennai

angular js training in bangalore

angular js training in hyderabad

angular js training in coimbatore

angular js training

angular js online training

ramesh said...


I am really enjoying reading your well written articles. It looks like you spend a lot of effort and time on your blog. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work.

Azure Training in Chennai

Azure Training in Bangalore

Azure Training in Hyderabad

Azure Training in Pune

Azure Training | microsoft azure certification | Azure Online Training Course

Azure Online Training

Ramya said...

very interesting to read this article.I would like to thank you for the efforts you had made for writing this awesome article. This article resolved my all queries.
DevOps Training in Chennai

DevOps Online Training in Chennai

DevOps Training in Bangalore

DevOps Training in Hyderabad

DevOps Training in Coimbatore

DevOps Training

DevOps Online Training

devi said...

I like the helpful info you supply in your articles. I’ll bookmark your weblog and take a look at once more here regularly. I am relatively certain I will learn a lot of new stuff right here! Good luck for the following!
Data Science Training In Chennai

Data Science Online Training In Chennai

Data Science Training In Bangalore

Data Science Training In Hyderabad

Data Science Training In Coimbatore

Data Science Training

Data Science Online Training

swaroop said...

very nice blogs!!! i have to learning for lot of information for this sites...Sharing for wonderful information.Thanks for sharing this valuable information to our vision. You have posted a trust worthy blog keep sharing.

Web Designing Training in Chennai

Web Designing Course in Chennai

Web Designing Training in Bangalore

Web Designing Course in Bangalore

Web Designing Training in Hyderabad

Web Designing Course in Hyderabad

Web Designing Training in Coimbatore

Web Designing Training

Web Designing Online Training


Revathi said...

I feel really happy to have seen your webpage.I am feeling grateful to read this.you gave a nice information for us.please updating more stuff content...keep up!!

Android Training in Chennai

Android Online Training in Chennai

Android Training in Bangalore

Android Training in Hyderabad

Android Training in Coimbatore

Android Training

Android Online Training

vivekvedha said...

Awesome..You have clearly explained ...Its very useful for me to know about new things..Keep on blogging.
acte chennai

acte complaints

acte reviews

acte trainer complaints

acte trainer reviews

acte velachery reviews complaints

acte tambaram reviews complaints

acte anna nagar reviews complaints

acte porur reviews complaints

acte omr reviews complaints

prabhu said...

Outstanding blog appreciating your endless efforts in coming up with an extraordinary content. Which perhaps motivates the readers to feel excited in grasping the subject easily. This obviously makes every readers to thank the blogger and hope the similar creative content in future too.
IELTS Coaching in chennai

German Classes in Chennai

GRE Coaching Classes in Chennai

TOEFL Coaching in Chennai

spoken english classes in chennai | Communication training

radhika said...

Another interesting articles .am amazed i am reading the articles one by one since yesterday night and every time i find a new article grabbing my attention within a post.



AWS Course in Bangalore

AWS Course in Hyderabad

AWS Course in Coimbatore

AWS Course

AWS Certification Course

AWS Certification Training

AWS Online Training

AWS Training


TAZEEN said...

As an experienced printed circuit boards assembly supplier in China, we enjoy our business partnership in each aspect of clients’ PCB needs

zoey said...

Turkish delight, iron rust, bubblegum, nutella, and bitter chocolate orange are among the
Finance Coursework
often changing unique flavours.

Anonymous said...

This is a very nice one and gives in-depth information. I am really happy with the quality and presentation of the article. I’d really like to appreciate the efforts you get with writing this post. Thanks for sharing.
Spoken English training in Mumbai

Leo Oliver said...



We offer Python Homework Help and assign Python coders to help you with all of your online assignment. Students can get Python homework help, as well as python coding assistance for assignments and programming issues. If you're growing terribly pressed to do your academic tasks. As a result, our top programmer can assist you with your python homework quickly.

periyannan said...

Amazing blog. Great share of information. Very useful

evs full form
raw agent full form
full form of tbh in instagram
dbs bank full form
https full form
tft full form
pco full form
kra full form in hr
tbh full form in instagram story
epc full form

shiash said...

good blog.
Recuritment process outsourcing in chennai

It Outsourcing in Chennai

Cloud computing in chennai

Enterprise applications in chennai

Product engineering in chennaiI

Data science program in chennai

Internship in chennai


medical coding services

medical transcription services

medical coding training