Friday, 3 January 2014

Judging a book by its URLs

It will sound odd, but I have recently had a great time editing URLs.  Robert Shoemaker and I have have just finished a book for CUP, derived from the London Lives project, and called - London Lives: Poverty, Crime and the Making of a Modern City, 1690-1800. It is a long book (170,000 words) and each quote and reference in it is linked via a URL to the original document or article, book or web-resource used as evidence or to contextualize the argument.  It will be published as both an ebook and in hard copy, and the links need to be robust, and secure.  My estimate is that there are in the region of 4,000 URLs included in the manuscript (which was written collaboratively in PMWiki).  In the end, I found that I could identify an appropriate link for 98% of all footnote references, but then had to eliminate around 10% of these, as the relevant URL was just not useable.  The book took some nine years, and I am glad it is finished.

One of my final jobs was editing those 4000 URLs.   It took about three months work, spread over the last year, and I have just finished spending a week or so confirming what I hope will be their final form.  When I have told people about this work many have looked incredulous and suggested that this is the sort of technical implementation process that should be left to others.  A couple of otherwise nice people have suggested I dump this job on the shoulders of the nearest PhD student.  But for myself, it is precisely the kind of thing that an author should do for themselves.  And in doing it, two things kept coming to mind.  First was how the role of the scholar in creating a rigorous academic apparatus is a central part of the intellectual journey that academic writing involves - and that we should see the implementation of the online version of this in the light of the precise writing of footnotes and references that mark out good scholarship.  And second, that URLs encode a system of design and intent, online architecture and system of access, that signal the quality and permanence (the academic credibility and perceived audience) of historical materials online.  And that just as we have always sorted and judged scholarship by its form, we should think a bit harder about how the form of a URL can let us interrogate online materials.

On the first point, I do not know of much discussion of the joys of this kind of academic slog.  There is a lot of good writing on research and archives (by Carolyn Steedman and Arlette Farge among many others), on writing and thinking, but no-one talks much about the painstaking labour that goes in to turning a rough draft in to a final finished piece of scholarship.  And here I am really talking about generating accurate and fully comprehensive footnotes that reflect both the material cited, and the research journey that resulted in the main text.   This has become much easier with online catalogs and citation management packages, but nevertheless remains laborious and a reflection of our collective and individual commitment to a particular kind of evidenced discussion.  But for me it also represents my favourite compromise.  The writing of history is a wonderfully imaginative and creative process.  And in some respects we wish to judge the product of history writing as art.  Is it enjoyable to read? Is it convincing?  Does it do the job of good writing in liberating the readers' imagination?  In making these judgements we tend to appeal to a notion of 'value' that is cultural and that privileges dominant forms of authority.  This aspect of judgement is essentially romantic; with all the implications for western and elite hegemony embedded in that idea.  At the same time history writing is the result of simple hard work of a more technical kind - in the archives, in collating and collecting, re-ordering and interrogating data.  And it is valuable because it encompasses that hard work.  The beauty of the academic apparatus is that it evidences this and in the process generates a different measure of value.  In other words it is where quality is tied to a 'labour theory of value'.  I love the academic slog because it is where un-moored judgement is tied down to hard labour; and where value can be universalized in a common human experience (work).  In other words I really enjoyed editing 4000 URLs precisely because in them and their associated footnotes lies a claim to and evidence of the hard labour that underpins the book itself.

 At the same time, the process also taught me to read URLs differently.  Clearly coders and web designers do this as a matter of course.  But I am a historian and want to read URLs as a scholar, rather than as a programmer or designer.  And for me, the important thing is that URLs embed the structure of a site, making it plain to see for anyone willing to look hard; and that they are made up of both the character of a library reference, and a command directed at the new technology of discovery - the Internet .  There are just lots of different types of URL.

There are 'Search URLs' that include all the elements that  take the user past a collection to a specific object, but don't let you go directly there without the query.  And there are URLs that encode a cataloging hierarchy.  There are URLs that sift data, or work in your browser to change the data delivered, highlighting phrases or sifting material.  And there are URLs that encode licensing, passwords, and access information.  It is easy enough to find that the whole search journey that took you from a library catalog to an individual item is encoded directly in the URL, and even personalized to you, the machine you are using, or the forms of access you can deploy.  It is easy to find URLs that run on for hundreds of characters, each element divided by a '&' or a '%', or such.

But in creating robust reproducible links to credible historical materials most of these URLs are at least problematic if not useless.  If they include details for institutional access, or session information, they cannot be re-used by someone else.  These URLs are friable and fragile things and not fit for scholarly purposes.  And as a result, for the London Lives book we have been forced to eliminate all the links we originally hoped to include to forty or fifty different sites.  To take a single example, most archives structure their online collections with search in mind, making it difficult to link to a single item.  I spent a lot of time finding the catalog entry for every manuscript we cited in the London Metropolitan Archives, and Westminster Archives Centre, only to regretfully strip out the links when confronted by a complex URL that just did not look credible as a long term citation of the item itself.

Even in its simplest, and in the form recommended by the site for sharing a link, a London Metropolitan Archives URL looks like this:

http://search.lma.gov.uk/scripts/mwimain.dll/144/LMA_OPAC/web_detail/REFD+P69~2FBRI~2FB~2F001~2FMS06554~2F004?SESSIONSEARCH


Since we had consulted these items in their physical form in any case, it did not seem too problematic to leave out these links, but a shame nevertheless.  And likewise, with paywall material there seemed little point in dangling real access, and the promise of credible evidence, before the eyes of readers who would not be able to go beyond the login screen.  It seemed better to cite a specific item in combination with a general (unlinked) URL and date of consultation as reflecting our own research journey, rather than to promise access when we could not deliver it.

With few exceptions the URLs that have been retained (and there are still 4000 of them) address specific items with a specific ID, and usually run to 20 to 40 characters.  DOIs are not bad once you figure out their structure and reformulate them as they should be, rather than the way they are normally cited on journal web pages.

dx.doi.org/10.1353/sec.2010.0268

And Google Books creates a very nice URL once you strip out all the complex formatting instructions that are normally generated as part of a search and inserted after the main ID.  This is what a Google Books' URL looks like if you were to use the 'search' version:

 http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=1sMJGt7_rTAC&printsec=frontcover&dq=%22Prosecution+and+Punishment:+Petty+Crime+and+the+Law%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=rrzGUq_aDsSy7Aa_9YGQCg&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=%22Prosecution%20and%20Punishment%3A%20Petty%20Crime%20and%20the%20Law%22&f=false

And this URL will take to the same book:

 books.google.co.uk/books?id=1sMJGt7_rTAC

 And the Eighteenth-century Short Title Catalog generates some of the most elegant URLs I have found:

estc.bl.uk/T174945

And to a lesser extent, so does the Ethos collection of doctoral theses at the British Library.

ethos.bl.uk/OrderDetails.do?uin=uk.bl.ethos.354762

And London Lives and the Old Bailey Online do pretty well on this score:

www.londonlives.org/browse.jsp?div=LMSMPS501980014
http://www.oldbaileyonline.org/browse.jsp?ref=t17910413-19


In part, I suspect that these issues would all disappear if I had a better sense of the layer of structure that lies beneath the WWW.  But for the moment I am keen to have a short, human-readable URL that looks like it will last longer than the session I am currently logged on for.   All of which simply takes me back to the joy of academic slogging and the importance of the academic apparatus as something that evidences hard work and opens up scholarship to credible criticism that goes beyond simple romantic appreciation and prejudice.

I know all too well that one of the skills of an academic is the ability to judge a book by its cover and the form of the text it contains.   For the online we need to embed URLs into precisely this process - and the joy of all that editing was that at the end of it, I feel I have learned to do just that.



122 comments:

Becky said...

I'm an academic librarian and spend a good bit of time explaining to students the value of a book's apparatus--references, index, table of contents--in descending order of importance, for the most part. This piece fits right in, and I appreciate your expressing so well how all the work of creating a book affects its quality.

I'll be searching your blog for any posts on indexes, my favorite scholarly tool.

Becky Kornegay

Tim Hitchcock said...

Hi Becky, Thanks for your comment - very much appreciated. And please keep up teaching students about book structures! I am continually depressed by the extent to which historians largely fail to do this.

Indexes are interesting - though I haven't blogged about them in particular (this blog is a bit random!). But what I have always wanted to try is turning traditional book indexes on their head, and using them to model reader response - essentially assuming that text that attracts human created index entries comprises text that the readers eye gravitated towards (even if it is only the eye of the indexer).

Tim Hitchcock

Janice said...

What a smart analysis. (And may I say that I'm excited for the book project which has inspired this post?)

It's difficult to get tech-phobic colleagues and students to understand that just copying the URL from their browser bar isn't going to create a durable URL that others can use. It's also maddening when the software or database choices for a project hamper the URL reusability - this should be a basic concern for anyone building a web project these days!

John Muccigrosso said...

I worry whenever there's a ? in a URL (URI, really). That usually means that the underlying search mechanism, which is liable to change, is being included. So when they switch out the engine in an upgrade, the reference won't work anymore.

For example, your London Lives URI is clearly using a little Java on the server. How long will that last?

I think the Eighteenth-century Short Title Catalog has the best URI: just an ID number after the /.

Sebastian Heath has got a few good posts on this. For example,

http://mediterraneanceramics.blogspot.com/2010/10/change-happens-if-it-can.html

Or his list of Very Clean URIs at

http://wiki.digitalclassicist.org/Very_clean_URIs

(Hmm, can I tag him here with @sebth?)

Kristopher Nelson said...

As a former web developer who is now a PhD student in history, this was fascinating--it's so ingrained in me to see URLs as reflections of what goes on behind the scenes that I often forget that this isn't how most people see them!

Anyway, just one thought: I am always suspicious of the durability of URLs that include a "?," even though this is extremely standard on so many sites. The "?" indicates that the bit after that is being passed on to another layer of the system that parses it as, effectively, a search. In my experience, if the backend technology changes, this part is the hardest to redirect to the proper resource.

I always prefer URLs that have only path information in them ("/"), because even though these still require backend tech to handle they tend to be the most stable into the future.

Of course, this is all very nice in theory! You do what you can, as you have, to reduce the complexity as much as possible.

This is an area where web devs could stand to pay attention historians/librarians/archivists, instead of just their immediate concerns.

Thanks for all the hard work on the project!

Tim Hitchcock said...

Dear All, Thanks for your comments. I particularly wanted to thank John for the link to Sebastian Heath's blog on this - I loved his line: If a URL looks unstable, it is.

But thanks also to both John and Kristopher for raising the issue of ? and the difficulties it creates. I am looking forward to discussing how to avoid this issue on the Old Bailey and London Lives sites.

One area that continues to interest me, is the effect that locating more and more functionality on the browser side of the equation, will have. One site I have been largely unable to reference effectively is Locating London's Past, just because the things I want to cite - maps - are generated on the fly, don't exist as 'objects' and don't actually show up in the URl.

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Unknown said...

I wonder if you have tried using the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine's "Save Page Now" tool to capture a page as it appeared when you accessed it for use as a trusted citation in the future? https://archive.org/web/web.php

Unknown said...

I wonder if you have tried using the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine's "Save Page Now" tool to capture a page as it appeared when you accessed it for use as a trusted citation in the future? https://archive.org/web/web.php

Unknown said...

I wonder if you have tried using the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine's "Save Page Now" tool to capture a page as it appeared when you accessed it for use as a trusted citation in the future? https://archive.org/web/web.php

Tim Hitchcock said...

I hadn't seen the 'Save Page Now' function - thanks very much for pointing me in this direction!

Phil said...

Just read this on the LSE Website. It reminded me of this old post; it expresses my own pleasure in reference-hunting, as well as a similar sense of how academic writing can combine the most unmoored and speculative creativity with a Gradgrindian level of groundedness ("Now, what I want is, References!"). Nothing like it, when it works.

Unknown said...

Hi, I am Jackson from Chennai. I am technology freak. I did Big Data Hadoop Training in Chennai at FITA. This is useful for me to make a bright career in IT field.

Melisa said...

I have read your blog, it was good to read & I am getting some useful info's through your blog keep sharing... Informatica is an ETL tools helps to transform your old business leads into new vision. Learn Informatica training in chennai from corporate professionals with very good experience in informatica tool.
Regards,
Best Informatica Training In Chennai|Informatica training center in Chennai

John Adam said...


your article is good information. i very like it, keep it up.

get more twitter followers instantly

Anonymous said...

Indeed a very good experience been shown this would also create some more values by the time and also there would be more things come to the mind if we would able to transcribe to our services. blog writing service

Unknown said...

Wiztech Automation is a Chennai based one-stop Training Centre/Institute for the Students Looking for Practically Oriented Training in Industrial Automation PLC, SCADA, DCS, HMI, VFD,VLSI, Embedded, and others – IT Software, Web Designing and SEO.

PLC Training in Chennai
Embedded Training in Chennai
VLSI Training in Chennai
DCS Training in Chennai
IT Training Institutes in Chennai
Web Designing Training in Chennai

Unknown said...

Superb explanation & it's too clear to understand the concept as well, keep sharing admin with some updated information with right examples.
Regards,

Hadoop Training in Chennai|Big Data Training in Chennai|Fita Chennai reviews

tanya sweet said...

First of all i am saying that i like your post very much.I am really impressed by the way in which you presented the content and also the structure of the post. Hope you can gave us more posts like this and i really appreciate your hardwork.


Kiss Day 2017
Happy New Year 2018 Quotes
attitude dp for whatsapp in hindi
Good Night Quotes
Birthday Wishes to Brother
Happy New Year 2017 Poems
Valentine Week List 2017

Anonymous said...

Valentine day Wishes
Valentine's day Wishes 2017
Valentine's day 2017
Valentine day Quotes
Valentine day Poem
Valentine day celebration with Girlfriend
Valentine's Week List 2017

Unknown said...

I love the creativity on this site. The title of the article is very interesting and unique and it propels the reader to read the entire article so that you can figure out why you should judge a book by its URL. I am looking forward to reading more articles from this site that will help me to improve my command of English and range of vocabulary which are important skills possessed by Proposal Editors.

anonymous said...

This is exceptionally decent blog and educational. I have looked numerous locales however was not ready to get data same as your site but if you visit the website then you meet your target. I extremely like the thoughts and exceptionally intersting to peruse so much and Please Update and I would love to peruse more from your site,Thanks

ashxyz said...

Thanks for sharing such an amazing blog,really useful and informative.

Website Design Course in Bangalore | Web Designing Course in Bangalore

Sebi said...

Really a usefull post . Thankyou
Website Developers | Web Designers in bangalore | Website Designing company in bangalore
| SEO services in bangalore

Cheating Playing Cards Development Company said...

cheating playing cards in India

Thanks For Sharing such beautiful information with us.I hope you will Share some more info about Cheating Playing in Delhi India.Please Keep Sharing...!

ptiacademy said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
srikanthsri said...


tutuapp vip
tutuapp apk
tutu app apk
tutuapp install
tutuapp download
The first version is specifically designed to provide users with unlimited free downloads of their favorite apps.

Unknown said...

Chinese New Year 2019 GIF

Birthday Wishes for Boss

Slap Day 2019

7 Feb to 21 Feb Days List

Aruna Ram said...

This blog is awesome! In this post is very interesting for all readers and I am waiting for your more post from this blog admin.

Embedded System Course Chennai
Embedded Course in chennai
Unix Training in Chennai
Power BI Training in Chennai
Tableau Training in Chennai
Oracle Training in Chennai
Pega Training in Chennai
Oracle DBA Training in Chennai
Embedded System Course Chennai
Embedded Training in Chennai

ptiacademy said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
htop said...

thanks for sharing this informations
aws training center in chennai
aws training in chennai
angularjs training in chennai
best hadoop training in chennai
best python training in chennai
selenium training in chennai
selenium training in omr

Entertaining Game Channel said...

This is Very very nice article. Everyone should read. Thanks for sharing. Don't miss WORLD'S BEST TrainDrivingSimulatorFreeGames

htop said...

thanks for sharing this information
aws training center in chennai
aws training in chennai
aws training institute in chennai
best angularjs training in chennai
angular js training in sholinganallur
angularjs training in chennai
azure training in chennai
best devops training in chennai

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing an informative blog Like "Judging a book by its URLs" Really useful.
bring more article
Google Ads Company
Google Ads services

Imcrinox said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

Very in depth article
Web Development Company in UAE
Mobile App Development Dubai
Mobile App Design Dubai
Mobile Application Development in Dubai
Web Development Company in UAE

Anbarasan14 said...

Informative blog! it was very useful for me.Thanks for sharing. Do share more ideas regularly.
English Speaking Classes in Mulund West
IELTS Classes in Mulund
German Classes in Mulund
French Classes in Mulund
Best Spoken English Classes in Chennai
IELTS Coaching Centre in Chennai
English Speaking Course in Mumbai
IELTS Coaching in Mumbai
Spoken English Class in T Nagar
IELTS Coaching in Anna Nagar

teez said...

happy national dog day 2019
national dog day captions
national dog day facts
national dog day cards


national dog day celebrations
national dog day USA

Suruchi Pandey said...

I glanced through a couple of articles on your blog and found them genuinely relevant to my search. Keep up with this worthwhile write-ups.
Website Designer in Lucknow | Web design company

Imcrinox said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
jacklinemelda said...

We are the best Marketing Paper Writing Services company providing Business Writing Service services written by highly skilled writers. Our writers are skillful in their areas of expertise since they have years of experience in their subject areas.

High Five said...

Happy Teacher's Day Lines
teachers day wishes cards
teacher thank you cards
appreciation quotes for teachers
happy teachers day poems 2019
Teachers day qoute 2019
inspirational message for teachers day
Teachers day quotes hindi
happy teachers day sms 2019

rocky said...

Very informative, I like the way, you have covered this article. You have covered it in very different manner. Thanks
berlin marathon Entry
berlin marathon Route
berlin marathon Results
berlin marathon Lottery
berlin marathon Prize Money

Livetrendnews said...

Great post I really like and enjoy this post. Great working with you
Lopamudra Raut Affairs
Click Here

Partha said...

Great work there.

সিংহ এবং ইঁদুর – ঈশপ এর গল্প | The Lion and The Mouse story in Bengali

nubsplastics said...

Nubs plastics is the leading Injection Molding Company in the California. Having excellent customer service in various Industries. Choose the best Best Injection Molding Company for best material.

Venkatesh CS said...

Thanks for sharing valuable information.
Digital Marketing training Course in Chennai
digital marketing training institute in Chennai
digital marketing training in Chennai
digital marketing course in Chennai
digital marketing course training in omr
digital marketing certification in omr
digital marketing course training in velachery
digital marketing training center in Chennai
digital marketing courses with placement in Chennai
digital marketing certification in Chennai
digital marketing institute in Chennai
digital marketing certification course in Chennai
digital marketing course training in Chennai
Digital Marketing course in Chennai with placement
digital marketing courses in Chennai

Plumbers Near me said...


Check out the best specialist for kidney stones and prostate cancer surgery at KUC.

high technologies solutions said...

very useful information shared by you. keep posting
tally training institute in delhi

tally training institute in noida

alekhya sweetie said...

kingroot
kingroot app
kingroot for pc
kingroot pc
download kingroot pc
Great site and a great topic as well i really get amazed to read this. Its really good.

Urology Health Care said...

There are different types of Prostate cancer surgery options available. Your doctor will decide which is the right treatment for you. Learn about Prostate cancer Treatment and Prostate cancer Surgery. Contact to "Best Doctors for Prostate Cancer" - KUC - 9915286238, 9814006238

Mindgourmet said...

Buy website traffic in the usa with real visitors. Purchase Web Traffic. Complete Control of your Traffic. Reach the Right Users. High Lifetime Value Users. Dedicated Targeting Solutions. Call us Today!!!!!!

sujeet kumar said...


Great article. Thanks for sharing info.
Digital marketing Course in hyderabad

iuwekjhbr said...

Please refer below if you are looking for best Online job support and proxy interview from India

DevOps Proxy Interview Support From India | PHP Proxy Interview Support From India | Selenium Proxy Interview Support From India | Hadoop Proxy Interview Support From India | Java Proxy Interview Support From India | Angular Proxy Interview Support From India | Python Proxy Interview Support From India | Android Proxy Interview Support From India

Thank you for excellent article.

Unknown said...

Please refer below if you are looking for best Online job support and proxy interview from India

AWS Proxy Interview Support From India | Workday Proxy Interview Support From India | ReactJS Proxy Interview Support From India | Manual Testing Proxy Interview Support From India | Dotnet Proxy Interview Support From India | Peoplesoft Proxy Interview Support From India | Teradata Proxy Interview Support From India

Thank you for excellent article.

Vijay said...

Thank you for the Article Submission. have a great experenced from this content



Digital Marketing Course in Hyderabad


RPA Training in Hyderabad | RPA Online Training

Pega Training in Hyderabad

AWS Training in Hyderabad

Digital Marketing Course in Hyderabad

Ashok said...

Thankyou for submitting great helpful information articles .

Digital Marketing Course in Hyderabad

RPA Course

Pega Training in Hyderabad Ameerpet

AWS Training in Hyderabad

Digital Marketing Course in Hyderabad

kamini kapoor said...


Nice BLOG!!
Robotics training in chennai
Internship for cse students in chennai
iot internship in chennai
Kaashiv infotech in bangalore
Free internship in chennai for mechanical engineering students
Inplant training
ECE internship in chennai
Internship for cse students in bangalore
Free internship for cse students in chennai
Internship for eee students in chennai


iuwekjhbr said...

Please refer below if you are looking for best Online job support and proxy interview from India

DevOps Online Job Support From India | PHP Online Job Support From India | Selenium Online Job Support From India | Hadoop Online Job Support From India | Java Online Job Support From India | Angular Online Job Support From India | Python Online Job Support From India | Android Online Job Support From India

Thank you for excellent article.

Brittney Emery said...

data protection impact assessment
data subject access request
Cookie policy generator
ccpa compliance

Brittney Emery said...

data protection impact assessment
data subject access request
Cookie policy generator
ccpa compliance

Data science said...

Hey there, You have done a fantastic job. I’ll definitely digg it and personally suggest to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this web site.

Data Science Training in Hyderabad
Hadoop Training in Hyderabad
selenium Online Training in Hyderabad
Devops Online Training in Hyderabad
Informatica Online Training in Hyderabad
Tableau Online Training in Hyderabad
Talend Online Training in Hyderabad

un known said...

I just loved your article on the beginners guide to starting a blog.If somebody take this blog article seriously in their life, he/she can earn his living by doing blogging.thank you for thizs article. top sap hana online training

Jack sparrow said...



I am really happy to say it’s an interesting post to read . I learn new information from your article , you are doing a great job . Keep it up and a i also want to share some information regarding selenium online training and selenium training videos

arun kumar said...

Thanks for Artical SarkariExamFind Sarkarieducation Upbharti and help full information.

du hoc canada vnsava said...

Class College Education training Beauty teaching university academy lesson teacher master student spa manager skin care learn eyelash extensions tattoo spray

daythammynet
daythammynet
daythammynet
daythammynet
daythammynet
daythammynet
daythammynet
daythammynet
daythammynet

Shruti said...

Pretty! This has been a really wonderful article. Many thanks for providing this information.

Selenium Courses in Marathahalli

selenium institutes in Marathahalli

selenium training in Bangalore

Selenium Courses in Bangalore

best selenium training institute in Bangalore

selenium training institute in Bangalore

Anurag Srivastava said...

By reading this article I get a lot of lessons and this is very useful....highly prefer railway jobs because it provides job security and attractive pay scale. Every people dream to get RRB Recruitment 2020 because they want to settle in earlier life time. For them getting a govt. job under railway sector is the best option

Sudharshan said...

Thank you for taking the time to provide us with your valuable information. We strive to provide our candidates with excellent care
http://chennaitraining.in/creo-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/building-estimation-and-costing-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/machine-learning-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/data-science-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/rpa-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/blueprism-training-in-chennai/

Shivani said...

You made some really good points there. I checked on the net to find out more about the issue and found most people will go along with your views on this web site.

Best Advanced Java Training In Bangalore Marathahalli

Advanced Java Courses In Bangalore Marathahalli

Advanced Java Training in Bangalore Marathahalli

Advanced Java Training Center In Bangalore

Advanced Java Institute In Marathahalli

SEO Service said...

I enjoy every one of the posts, I must say i adored, I want more details with this, mainly because it is rather excellent., Thanks pertaining to speaking about. satta king

SEO Service said...

That's why it is best that you relevant researching previously penning. You're able to construct more desirable put up this way. Satta king

Clash of Magic said...

This was really helping & the writer has some good approach towards what he/she is writing, i have found something relevant to this related to Data Protection act 2018
and
NIS

Clash of Magic said...

PECR Cookie Requirement

GDPR Audit

shiva said...


Frontier Mail Login
I hope I could find more updates from you. Thank you for sharing the nice article. I learned a lot from it

Sudharshan said...

Thank you for taking the time to provide us with your valuable information. We strive to provide our candidates with excellent care
http://chennaitraining.in/creo-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/building-estimation-and-costing-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/machine-learning-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/data-science-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/rpa-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/blueprism-training-in-chennai/

Sudharshan said...

Great blog !It is best institute.Top Training institute In chennai
http://chennaitraining.in/openspan-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/uipath-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/automation-anywhere-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/microsoft-azure-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/workday-training-in-chennai/
http://chennaitraining.in/vmware-training-in-chennai/

Imcrinox said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Brittney Emery said...

gdpr cookie consent examples

GDPR Cookie Consent

Unknown said...

gdpr cookie consent examples

GDPR Cookie Consent

Brittney Emery said...

DPIA

PECR Cookie Requirement

meritstep Technology said...

Thanks for Sharing This Article.It is very so much valuable content. I hope these Commenting lists will help to my website
workday studio online training
best workday studio online training
top workday studio online training

meritstep Technology said...

Thanks for Sharing This Article.It is very so much valuable content. I hope these Commenting lists will help to my website
blockchain online training
best blockchain online training
top blockchain online training

meritstep Technology said...

Thanks for Sharing This Article.It is very so much valuable content. I hope these Commenting lists will help to my website
workday studio online training
best workday studio online training
top workday studio online training

saloni said...

Very useful information work day online training Make yourself an expert and be trained with our high professional trainers for workday HCM online training provided by Evantatech.

meritstep Technology said...

Thanks for Sharing This Article.It is very so much valuable content. I hope these Commenting lists will help to my website
servicenow online training
best servicenow online training
top servicenow online training

Rohit said...

Great Article & Thanks for sharing.

Oflox Is The Best Digital Marketing Company In Dehradun Or Digital Marketing Institute In Dehradun

PackingServiceInc said...

nationwide shipping services
flat rate pallet shipping

Doctor Locksmith Tucson said...

The best locksmith for pop a lock in tucson, Catch the best key maker in the Arizona Town.

assignmentauthors said...

Most of the employees can hardly trace to what attribute are the delays in the system that makes the students so impatient.assignment expert

vijay said...

Thanks you for Sharing valuable information

Procareer Online IT Trainings
Contact US

Unknown said...

Hi to all, the contents present at this website are truly awesome for people experience, well, keep up the good work fellows.
Website Design Bengaluru

modelpapers2021 said...

MP Board 12th Class Blueprint 2021 English Medium & Hindi Medium PDF download, MPBSE 12th Blueprint 2021 Pdf Download, mpbse.nic.in 12th Blue Print, Marking Scheme and Arts, Commerce and Science Streams Chapter wise Weightage pdf download. MP Board 12th Blue Print || MPBSE 12th Model Papers || MPBSE 10th Model Papers

Manabadi AP Intermediate 2nd Year Model Question Paper 2021 MPC, BIPC, CEC, MEC group TM, EM Subject wise Blue Print, Download BIEAP Intermediate Second Year Model Question Papers, AP Senior Inter Test Papers, Chapter wise important Questions download. || AP Inter MPC, Bi.PC, CEC Blue Print || AP Inter 1st / 2nd Year Model Papers || AP 2nd year inter Test Papers

Kar 1st / 2nd PUC Blue Print || UP Board 12th Blueprint 2021

meldaresearch said...

Online biology essay services have come up with Biology Essay Writing Services for biology research paper writing service students in order for them to score straight A’s in their custom biology research paper services.

Unknown said...

Hi to all, the contents present at this website are truly awesome for people experience, well, keep up the good work fellows.
Web Development Design Bengaluru

Florahmelda said...

To seek the best Healthcare Assignment Writing Services for those studying healthcare coursework writing services, it is important to hire an award winning healthcare essay writing service company.

Unknown said...

A very excellent blog post. I am thankful for your blog post. I have found a lot of approaches after visiting your post.
art pieces miami

dhinesh said...

Excellent Blog! I would Thanks for sharing this wonderful content.its very useful to us.
gained many unknown information, the way you have clearly explained is really fantastic.keep posting such useful information.
Full Stack Training in Chennai | Certification | Online Training Course
Full Stack Training in Bangalore | Certification | Online Training Course

Full Stack Training in Hyderabad | Certification | Online Training Course
Full Stack Developer Training in Chennai | Mean Stack Developer Training in Chennai
Full Stack Training

Full Stack Online Training


Aishu said...

Wow I can say that this is another great article as expected of this blog.Bookmarked this site.Thanks for sharing.Keep sharing more blogs like this.
IELTS Coaching in chennai

German Classes in Chennai

GRE Coaching Classes in Chennai

TOEFL Coaching in Chennai

spoken english classes in chennai | Communication training

Geremy said...

To be honest I found very helpful information your blog thanks for providing us such blog prediction updates

lavanya said...

This is really good post here. Thanks for taking the time to post such valuable information. Quality content is what always gets the visitors coming.Java training in Chennai

Java Online training in Chennai

Java Course in Chennai

Best JAVA Training Institutes in Chennai

Java training in Bangalore

Java training in Hyderabad

Java Training in Coimbatore

Java Training

Java Online Training

keerthana said...

I am really happy with your blog because your article is very unique and powerful for new reader.Prefer to study this kind of material. Nicely written information in this post,the quality of content is fine and the conclusion is lovely. Things are very open and intensely clear explanation of issues. PHP Training in Chennai | Certification | Online Training Course | Machine Learning Training in Chennai | Certification | Online Training Course | iOT Training in Chennai | Certification | Online Training Course | Blockchain Training in Chennai | Certification | Online Training Course | Open Stack Training in Chennai |
Certification | Online Training Course

surya said...

I have read your blog, it was good to read & I am getting some useful info's through your blog keep sharing...

angular js training in chennai

angular training in chennai

angular js online training in chennai

angular js training in bangalore

angular js training in hyderabad

angular js training in coimbatore

angular js training

angular js online training

swaroop said...

This post is really nice and informative. The explanation given is really comprehensive and informative..

Web Designing Training in Chennai

Web Designing Course in Chennai

Web Designing Training in Bangalore

Web Designing Course in Bangalore

Web Designing Training in Hyderabad

Web Designing Course in Hyderabad

Web Designing Training in Coimbatore

Web Designing Training

Web Designing Online Training

Ramya said...

A befuddling web diary I visit this blog, it's incredibly grand. Strangely, in this present blog's substance made motivation behind fact and sensible. I just loved your article on the beginners guide to starting a blog.If somebody take this blog article seriously in their life.
DevOps Training in Chennai

DevOps Online Training in Chennai

DevOps Training in Bangalore

DevOps Training in Hyderabad

DevOps Training in Coimbatore

DevOps Training

DevOps Online Training

radhika said...

This is excellent information. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site.Thanks for sharing this information,this is useful to me...

AWS training in Chennai

AWS Online Training in Chennai

AWS training in Bangalore

AWS training in Hyderabad

AWS training in Coimbatore

AWS training

radhika said...

This is excellent information. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site.Thanks for sharing this information,this is useful to me...

AWS training in Chennai

AWS Online Training in Chennai

AWS training in Bangalore

AWS training in Hyderabad

AWS training in Coimbatore

AWS training

harshni said...

Quite Interesting post!!! Thanks for posting such a useful post. I wish to read your upcoming post to enhance my skill set, keep blogging.I am reading your post from the beginning, it was so interesting to read & I feel thanks to you for posting such a good blog, keep updates regularly.
Artificial Intelligence Training in Chennai

Ai Training in Chennai

Artificial Intelligence training in Bangalore

Ai Training in Bangalore

Artificial Intelligence Training in Hyderabad | Certification | ai training in hyderabad

Artificial Intelligence Online Training

Ai Online Training

Blue Prism Training in Chennai

sathya said...

Nice post. Thanks for sharing! I want people to know just how good this information is in your article. It’s interesting content and Great work. nice to read.
selenium training in chennai

selenium training in chennai

selenium online training in chennai

selenium training in bangalore

selenium training in hyderabad

selenium training in coimbatore

selenium online training

selenium training


anand said...

very nice post
Software Testing Training in Chennai | Certification | Online
Courses

Software Testing Training in Chennai

Software Testing Online Training in Chennai

Software Testing Courses in Chennai

Software Testing Training in Bangalore

Software Testing Training in Hyderabad

Software Testing Training in Coimbatore

Software Testing Training

Software Testing Online Training

Rashika said...

This post is really nice and informative. The explanation given is really comprehensive and informative..

Digital Marketing Training in Chennai

Digital Marketing Course in Chennai

SEO Training in Chennai

Digital Marketing Training in Bangalore

Digital Marketing Training in Hyderabad

Digital Marketing Training in Coimbatore

Digital Marketing Training

Digital Marketing Course

Digital Marketing Online Training

Revathi said...

Prefer to study this kind of material. Nicely written information in this post,the quality of content is fine and the conclusion is lovely.
tanks for your information ,, nice

android training in chennai

android online training in chennai

android training in bangalore

android training in hyderabad

android Training in coimbatore

android training

android online training

Joyal said...

Good post and informative. Thank you very much for sharing this good article, it was so good to read and useful to improve my knowledge as updated, keep blogging.Thank you for sharing wonderful information with us to get some idea about that content.
oracle training in chennai

oracle training institute in chennai

oracle training in bangalore

oracle training in hyderabad

oracle training

oracle online training

hadoop training in chennai

hadoop training in bangalore

vivekvedha said...

great blog and nice blog so informative thanks for sharing.
acte reviews

acte velachery reviews

acte tambaram reviews

acte anna nagar reviews

acte porur reviews

acte omr reviews

acte chennai reviews

acte student reviews

rocky said...

Your Post is very unique and all information is reliable for new readers. Keep it up in future, thanks for sharing such a useful post.

python training in chennai

python course in chennai

python online training in chennai

python training in bangalore

python training in hyderabad

python online training

python training

python flask training

python flask online training

python training in coimbatore

sanjay said...

You have provided a nice article, Thank you very much for this one. And I hope this will be useful for many people.
Cyber Security Training Course in Chennai | Certification | Cyber Security Online Training Course | Ethical Hacking Training Course in Chennai | Certification | Ethical Hacking Online Training Course |
CCNA Training Course in Chennai | Certification | CCNA Online Training Course | RPA Robotic Process Automation Training Course in Chennai | Certification | RPA Training Course Chennai | SEO Training in Chennai | Certification | SEO Online Training Course

hyder31 said...

Nice Blog

Digital Marketing Course in Hyderabad

Sunder said...

Gret Content & Thanks For Sharing, But Do you Want to know about How To Make Money With Hostgator Affiliate Program

Chavi. Appfinz said...

Excellent pieces. Keep writing such kind of information on your
page. Im really impressed by it.
Hi there, You have performed a great job. I’ll certainly digg
it and in my opinion recommend to my friends.
I am confident they’ll be benefited from this web site.

website designing company in karol bagh

website designing company in pitampura

website designing company in rohini

website designing company in noida
responsive web design company in india
website designing company in noida
website development company in delhi
wordpress development company delhi
magento development company in delhi

meritstep Technology said...

Thanks for Sharing This Article.It is very so much valuable content. I hope these Commenting lists will help to my website
mulesoft online training
best mulesoft online training
top mulesoft online training

meritstep said...

I just loved your article on the beginners guide to starting a blog.If somebody take this blog article seriously
in their life, he/she can earn his living by doing blogging.Thank you for this article.
best tibco sportfire online training

meritstep said...

comment pega :I just loved your article on the beginners guide to starting a blog.If somebody take this blog article seriously in their life,
he/she can earn his living by doing blogging.thank you for thizs article. pega online training