Wednesday 27 February 2013

Drills and holes

I have just spent a couple of days at the annual conference of the NFAIS (National Federation of Advanced Information Services) in Philadelphia.  I was giving a brief paper at the request of the good people at the British Library about developments in text mining in the Humanities, and I was happy to be invited and to participate.

But it was only when I had sat through a day or two of presentations that I realised just how out of place I was, and how irrelevant my comments were.  It turns out the NFAIS is the trade organisation for all the companies (and some libraries) that have been building a commercial operation for a hundred years by placing themselves between information and those who need it.  Thompson-Reuters were heavily represented, as was Cengage/Gale, several medical abstracting services, and a host of companies providing data to particular sectors of the economy such as the building trades and architects.   And they were all presenting their well articulated models of data gathering and manipulation designed to deliver a pablum of stuff to the desktops of America's commercial movers, shakers and capitalists.  Interestingly, the people who weren't there, were Google, Facebook, Twitter, the Creative Commons or representatives of the Open Access movement.  Neither new model capitalists, nor Open Access evangelists were present.  And while there was a strand of discussion focussed on research and academic library services, this was a small corner of an essentially old style commercial ecology.  Nor were the real innovations in data modelling and analysis coming out of CS on display.  A constant sub-theme of the conference seemed to be a tetchy criticism of Google for having done a half-arsed job of inter-mediating between data and users, while the Twitter stream for this event was almost non-existent.  It was clear that these data professionals were having their conversation somewhere else - though I never did find out where. 

There was a lot of talk about Altmetrics as a way of adding value to the data people already had, prior to selling it to the managers of research and education.  And the theme of the event appeared to be a call to extend a hundred year old business model to ensure that these companies were delivering precisely the data that people needed (rather than what they thought they wanted), in a form that allowed them to use that data without thinking.  The controlling metaphor was - people buy a drill, because they really want a hole.

I was bemused by this.  I don't want a hole.  I want a drill, a hammer, a saw and a workshop to make stuff in.  And I certainly don't want anyone else to second guess what it is I am making (perhaps wonky, but original).

And then it occurred to me where my disconnect came from.  The NFAIS and the companies they represent derive from a long and largely American tradition of late Enlightenment data processing.  Their origins lie in Union Catalogues and abstracting services via microfilm; in creating a pre-digested, post-Enlightenment world of understood data, that could be packaged and catalogued and sold as yard after yard of uniform reference volumes. NFAIS used to stand for the National Federation of Abstracting and Information Services. I have always put the American obsession with this kind of thing down to its inability to get over the European Enlightenment long after the rest of us got bored.

My overwhelming impression was that all these companies were anxious to widen the gap between data and its users, to ensure that they continued to have a role and an income - tapping the stream between the two for annual profit.  Some of the work was reasonably sophisticated (though most of it felt more 'relational database' than anything more innovative), and it was clear that many saw the way forward as providing faster access to real-time data in a form that would become normalised in a business context (or well funded, close to market STEM).  

In retrospect, and after having heard the presentations which came after my own, what I really should have said more forcefully, is get out of the way, this is boring, and it misses the point entirely.  We are rapidly approaching the stage when the devil's contract between private companies and the public sector, which has governed data delivery in both the humanities and STEM for the last fifteen years on line (and a hundred years off-line) is going to break down.  Open Access, for example, is just a wedge issue for a wider re-thinking of how research and data, and its users will interact.  And the fact that both the British and American governments were there first, is an indication that this particular community is not paying sufficient attention.

I am not overly exercised by the profiteering of these companies (if people want to sell their souls for a health plan and a cheap suit, that is OK by me).  Nor do I really want to castigate them for their place in an information food chain.  Companies like Cengage/Gale have coralled a useful amount of money for data processing.  I am just struck by the lack of serious engagement with the real changes in the fundamental relationship between the production and consumption of data that the last fifteen years has wrought.  More than anything else, my three days in Phili has brought home to me that I simply don't inhabit the same data universe that I did fifteen years ago. 


Janet Parfitt said...

Very interesting post!

Simon Tanner said...

Tim - you hit this particular nail straight on its head. I for one am glad you were there even if you were the alternate universe voice in the room.

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
sathya shri said...

Great content thanks for sharing this informative blog which provided me technical information keep posting.

angularjs Training in bangalore

angularjs Training in btm

angularjs Training in electronic-city

angularjs Training in online

angularjs Training in marathahalli

Mounika said...

Thanks for your informative article, Your post helped me to understand the future and career prospects & Keep on updating your blog with such awesome article.
python training Course in chennai | python training in Bangalore | Python training institute in kalyan nagar

Unknown said...

Excellent post!!!. The strategy you have posted on this technology helped me to get into the next level and had lot of information in it.

Data Science course in Indira nagar
Data Science course in marathahalli
Data Science Interview questions and answers

Praylin S said...

Very informative post! Thanks for sharing.
Oracle Training in Chennai | Oracle Training institute in chennai | Oracle course in Chennai | Oracle Training | Oracle Certification in Chennai | Best oracle training institute in Chennai | Best oracle training in Chennai | Oracle training center in Chennai | Oracle institute in Chennai | Oracle Training near me

srikanthsri said...

imo install
imo beta
imo messenger
imo online
YouMail is known for its state-of-art voicemail and visual experience.

918kiss malaysia said...

I am really very agree with your qualities it is very online casino malaysia free credit helpful for look like home. Thanks so much for info and keep it up.

Johan said...

Thanks for this. I really like what you've posted here and wish you the best of luck with this blog and thanks for sharing.

oracle training in bangalore

sql server dba training in bangalore

web designing training in bangalore

digital marketing training in bangalore

java training in bangalore

Johan said...

Many websites have differenet information but in your blog you shared unique and useful information. Thanks

tableau training in bangalore

tableau courses in bangalore

tableau classes in bangalore

tableau training institute in bangalore

tableau course syllabus

best tableau training

tableau training centers

Sophie Grace said...

Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me. Realm of magic has appeared on PC. Coming on game sims 4 cheats

karanroy said...

आज आप जानेंगे Vitamin B12 Sources in Hindi के बारे में. इसके आलावा आपको बेस्ट Vitamin b12 sources for vegetarians in Hindi से भी रूभरू कराया जाएगा.
विटामिन बी के समूह को विटामिन बी कॉम्प्लेक्स कहा जाता है। विटामिन बी कॉम्प्लेक्स में कुल 8 प्रकार के विटामिन होते हैं।
Vitamin B12 Sources in Hindi | HealthUpay.Com, Vitamin B12 Sources For Vegetarians In Hindi

Promote Abhi - Business Chalega Tabhi/Startup Development Company said...

Promote ABHI offer affordable Online Reputation Management(ORM) services are about this only. A top online reputation management company will not wait for any detrimental thing for your reputation to happen they will proactively check it to control that such things never occur.

kate said...

Discussion boards can also be used to further employ the resources of the Internet by allowing students to include hyperlinks to relevant content. Since discussion boards are asynchronous, they offer an opportunity for conversation that again cannot be found within the classroom environment write my discussion board post

ankit pal said...

If square measure feeling|you feel} like you have got lost the zeal and intimacy of your sexual life then a reliables sexologist in Delhi are a few things that you just actually would like. He has registered himself within the list of the highest purported sexologist. you've got got it here! he's Associate in Nursing honorable name within the trade of sexologist treatment. and best sexologist in Delhi or top sexologist in Faridabad.

aditya sure said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
HopeO said...

Thanks for the article. A health plan is indeed a necessary thing to do. Especially it can benefit your life and the organs of your body. Organs are one of the most important bases of any living body. If you are facing any malfunctions regarding your organ you can contact organ transplant center for healthcare tips and medical surgeries.