Monday, 27 April 2015

Voices of Authority: Towards a history from below in patchwork



This post is intended to very briefly describe a project I am about halfway through - that seeks to experiment with the new permeability that digital technologies seem to make possible - to create a more usable 'history from below', made up of lives knowable only through small fragments of information.

This particular project is called ‘Voices of Authority’, and is a small part of a larger AHRC funded project – The Digital Panopticon – that is seeking to digitise and link up the records reflecting everyone tried in London between around 1780 and 1875, and either sent to prison, or else transported to Australia.  This small element of the wider project is bringing together a series of different ways of knowing about a particular place, time and experience – the Old Bailey courtroom from around 1750-1850, and the experience of being tried for your life and for your liberty.  The conceit behind this project, is really a suggestion that building something in three dimensions, with space, physical form and performance, along with new forms of analysis of text; can change how we understand the experience of the trial process; and to allow a more fully empathetic engagement with defendants; along with a better understanding of how their experience impacted on the exercise of power and authority.

This project is only half completed – so this is very much a report of 'work in progress'.  But, in essence, what seeks to do is bring together three distinct different forms of ‘data’ and to re-organise that data around individual defendants.  

First, it takes the text of the Old Bailey Proceedings – the trial accounts of some 197,745 trials held between 1674 and 1913, and recognises them as comprising two different and distinct things – a bureaucratic record of the trials themselves (names, verdicts, punishments); and at the same time, one of the largest corpora of recorded spoken language created prior to the twentieth century – some 40 million words of direct, recorded testimony for the period under analysis.

These understandings of the Proceedings are, of course, built on projects of much longer duration; including the OldBailey Online, and more particularly, on Magnus Huber’s additional linguistic mark-up of the Proceedings, which allows ‘speech’ to be pulled from the trial text, and to identify the speaker along the way.  This is available via the Old Bailey Corpus.



The project also builds on text and data mining methodologies – including direct counting of word and phrase distributions, and the application of a form of explicit semantic analysis, that allows us to look at the changing character of language used in witness statements over the course of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.
 

In other words, the first element of the project is the text and speech, crimes, punishments and dates provided by the Old Bailey Proceedings.

The second element is the body of the criminal - the physical body of the individual  men and women involved.  The broader project is creating a dataset of some 66,000 men and women – with substantial and detailed information about their lives, both before and after transportation or imprisonment – reflecting the inter-relationship between the people who became defendants and criminals with the systems of a global empire. And this material provides a huge amount of data about bodies – to add to the words individuals spoke to power.  Height, weight, eye colour, tattoos among a range of other aspects of a physical self.  Suddenly, we know if a collection of words was spoken by a ten stone, 5 foot two inch woman with brown hair and black eyes, and a withered left arm; or by a six foot man with an anchor tattoo on his left arm, and a scar above squinting blue eyes. 

To think about it another way, this bit of the ‘project’, allows us to worry about the ragged boundary between the ‘physical’ as recorded in a set of numerical and standardised descriptions, and the ‘textual’ – the slippery and ambiguous content of each witness statement. 

In relation to ‘history from below’, this allows us to put together the lives of people like William Curtis, who as a 16 year old, in the summer of 1843, had a perfectly healthy tooth pulled, before stealing the dentists’ coat.  And Sarah Durrant, who was convicted for receiving two banks notes worth 2000 pounds. It all allows us to know their words (their textualities), and at the same time to see them as part of a different kind of truth – of place and body. 

The aspiration is to essentially code for the variabililties of body type at scale, to add a further dimension to both the records of the bureaucracy of trials (charge, verdict punishment), and the measurable content of the textualities of those same trials.

And finally, we are adding one additional dimension – space –  a ‘scene of trial’.

For this we are first of all building on a project called Locating London’s Past, which among other things, maps crime locations on to the historic landscape of London.  And to this we are adding a reconstruction of the courtroom, where all these trials took place. 

Simply using Sketch-up, we have made most progress on the George Dance’s building, finished in the late 1770s and providing the main venue for the relevant trials for the next hundred years – basing the models on the architectural plans from which it was built.  



In the process of creating this model, huge amounts of imformation about trial procedure has been revealed, including the changing layout of the court, and the relative position of the different speakers.  The design itself reflects a hitherto unacknowledged transition in the character of how witnesses and defendants were divided in this evolving space, evidencing a new story of the evolution of the criminal trial. 



The architecture itself, suggests that there was a clear transition from a situation in which witnesses and victims stood in a similar relation to the judge and jury (both facing the judge, relatively close to one another); to one - like a modern anglo-american courtroom  - where the judge and witnesses are on one side, and the defendant on the opposite side of the courtroom.  In other words, the character of the adversarial relationship at the core of the adversarial trial was re-defined, with the witnesses and victim re-located on the either side of the argument, and the judges role, redefined as arbiter between them.  At some level, in the process community resolution was replaced by court judgement. 



If you want to explain why conviction rates at the Old Bailey rose from under 50% in the mid eighteenth century, to over eighty percent at the end of the nineteenth century, starting from precisely the moment when the courtroom was rebuilt, this ‘fact on the ground’ needs to be part of the story.

What has also been revealed is the importance of levels – with lawyers speaking upwards to the judge, jury, witnesses and defendant, from a cock-pit several feet below their eye level.  Like a theatre audience, the judge, jury and defendant looked down on the stage below.  In other words, what was created, at least for a short time (70 years), was the real feel of a ‘theatre’ in which, as a barrister, you were forced to perform to the gods.  


 

Looking forwarding to the next stage, this particular sub-project is seeking to move from the ‘art’ of making and performance, through a humanist and historical appreciation of ‘experience’, towards the tools of social science and informatics – seeking to combine the close reading of a single desperate plea, with the empathy that can only come with physical knowledge, with that macroscopic image of all the similar words spoken over a hundred years – how that one plea fits in a universe of words and bodies.  And all of this, is in turn, being undertaken in pursuit of a more nuanced and empathetic engagement with the lives of working people - both for its own sake, and as part of a new analysis of the workings of power 'from below'.

With luck, this will allow us to move beyond a simple analysis of the courtroom, and the ‘adversarial trial’ - to an analysis through which we can see the whole system from the defendants’ perspectiv.

In other words, the next step is about creating a history of the British criminal justice system, and of transportation from an experiential perspective on a large scale – contributing to a history of common human experience, evidenced from the distributed leavings of the dead, analysed with all the approaches available to hand, from all the perspectives available.

38 comments:

James Baker said...

Hi Tim - re the sketch up model, you've got me thinking about modeling light levels and climatic conditions in their courtroom as a context to authority (your 'radical recontextualisation' thought comes to mind). I don't suppose the Old Bailey records mention such things, but I'm guessing the former could be grabbed from other sources and made to shine into the courtroom at appropriate angles, intensities, et cetera for certain trials.

Tim Hitchcock said...

Definitely - the sun is not a problem, and once you put the model in Google Earth you can calculate the hieght and direction etc, and the weather - cloud, rain and temperature - are avaialable from Greenwich from 1741 (or so) onwards (which I understand the climate scientists have digitised somewhere or other). It would be even more fun with the open-sided courtroom before 1780 or so. And of course, once down that route the weather on hanging days at Tyburn is beckoning. Of course, I tried using weather details to create 'atmosphere' in the Down and Out book, and my fiercest critic says it makes it read like: A dark and stormy night...

James Baker said...

Regardless of the 'critics', I'd certainly be intrigued at how light maps with the location and sightlines of witness, victim, judge, crowd.

Adam Crymble said...

If you're a defendant, I suppose you wouldn't want your jury members to have a low arching sun glaring in their eyes all day, would you?

Vinoth Kumar said...

Wiztech Automation is a Chennai based one-stop Training Centre/Institute for the Students Looking for Practically Oriented Training in Industrial Automation PLC, SCADA, DCS, HMI, VFD,VLSI, Embedded, and others – IT Software, Web Designing and SEO.

PLC Training in Chennai
Embedded Training in Chennai
VLSI Training in Chennai
DCS Training in Chennai
IT Training Institutes in Chennai
Web Designing Training in Chennai

Christopher Hanson said...

Digital technology helping all different professions those are connected or not. With the passage of time it's growing fast. personal statement for nursing

mathew delport said...

Hi excellent article, you can also consider taking embedded training in Chennai to secure career in IT industry. As embedded systems are heart of every larger machine, it offers huge career prospects for talented professionals.

Semicon Technologies said...

Hello,
This is very awesome and excellent articles. Thanks for sharing. asic verification training in bangalore|VLSI Training in Bangalore

Rohit P said...

That was really very informative article

found worth reading

do post more


world class seo training is give at very affordable price
seo training in bangalore

kanaksoni said...

After the huge success of Galaxy S8, Samsung is ready to launch the next generation of its flagship device the Galaxy S9 soon. It will have a more
powerful processor and a better back camera with dual tone LED flash. 4 Galaxy S9 all updates , it is a future generation smartphone.

sujitha said...

It’s too good information
Best of Social media seminar in Chennai/DMI

kanaga seo said...

Thank you a lot for providing individuals with a very spectacular possibility to read critical reviews from this site. .

Embedded training in chennai | Embedded training centre in chennai | Embedded system training in chennai | PLC Training institute in chennai | IEEE final year projects in chennai | VLSI training institute in chennai

Ram said...

Very impressive and interesting blog, There is a huge demand for hadoop. Hadoop training in Hyderabad

pavankanna said...

Amazing!!!! Superb work you have done. I appreciate for your patience and the thought which made you to take this topic to explain. Keep posting, Thank you.
Big Data Hadoop online training in USA,UK, Singapore
Hadoop online training in Delhi

pooja saravanan said...

This is an awesome post.Really very informative and creative contents. These concept is a good way to enhance the knowledge.I like it and help me to development very well.Thank you for this brief explanation and very nice information.Well, got a good knowledge.

Hadoop Training in Chennai

Hadoop Training in Bangalore

Big data training in tambaram

Big data training in Sholinganallur

Big data training in annanagar

Big data training in Velachery

Big data training in Marathahalli

shaik imam basha said...

The great service in this blog and the nice technology is visible in this blog. Thanks for sharing
data science online training in hyderabad

gowsalya said...

The knowledge of technology you have been sharing thorough this post is very much helpful to develop new idea. here by i also want to share this.
Devops Training in pune|Devops training in tambaram|Devops training in velachery|Devops training in annanagar
DevOps online Training

amala said...

Your good knowledge and kindness in playing with all the pieces were very useful. I don’t know what I would have done if I had not encountered such a step like this.

rpa training in Chennai | rpa training in pune

rpa training in tambaram | rpa training in sholinganallur

rpa training in Chennai | rpa training in velachery

rpa online training | rpa training in bangalore

amala said...

Your good knowledge and kindness in playing with all the pieces were very useful. I don’t know what I would have done if I had not encountered such a step like this.

rpa training in Chennai | rpa training in pune

rpa training in tambaram | rpa training in sholinganallur

rpa training in Chennai | rpa training in velachery

rpa online training | rpa training in bangalore

john jersy said...

Very good brief and this post helped me alot. Say thank you I searching for your facts. Thanks for sharing with us!
python training in Bangalore
python training in pune
python online training
python training in chennai

afiah ahamed said...

Wow it is really wonderful and awesome thus it is very much useful for me to understand many concepts and helped me a lot. it is really explainable very well and i got more information from your blog.

java training in chennai | java training in bangalore

java online training | java training in pune

nivetha nivs said...

Very nice post here thanks for it I always like and search such topics and everything connected to them.Excellent and very cool idea and the subject at the top of magnificence and I am happy to comment on this topic through which we address the idea of positive re like this.

http://www.attendasoft.com/offshore-project-management
http://www.attendasoft.com/near-shore-consulting
http://www.attendasoft.com/offshore-project-management
http://www.attendasoft.com/creative-writing-services

sagar sagar said...

I value your endeavors since it passes on the message of what you are attempting to state. It's an extraordinary expertise to make even the individual who doesn't think about the subject could ready to comprehend the subject. Your web journals are justifiable and furthermore extravagantly depicted. I would like to peruse an ever increasing number of intriguing articles from your blog. Continue Sharing
Tableau online training in Noida
Online Tableau training in Pune

Ram priya said...

Thank you for sharing this unique useful information content with us. Really awesome work. keep on blogging

Data Science training in kalyan nagar | Data Science training in OMR
Data Science training in chennai | Data science training in velachery
Data science training in jaya nagar

cynthia williams said...

Excellent and useful blog admin, I would like to read more about this topic.
RPA Training in Chennai
RPA courses in Chennai
DevOps Training in Chennai
Blue Prism Training in Chennai
UiPath Training in Chennai
R Training in Chennai

chitra pragya said...

Awesome! Education is the extreme motivation that open the new doors of data and material. So we always need to study around the things and the new part of educations with that we are not mindful.
angularjs Training in chennai
angularjs Training in chennai

angularjs-Training in tambaram

angularjs-Training in sholinganallur

angularjs-Training in velachery

Sai Elakiyaa said...

This is the best article on recent technology. Thanks for taking your own time to share your knowledge,
Selenium Training in Chennai
Best selenium training in chennai
iOS Training in Chennai
Digital Marketing Training in Chennai
.Net coaching centre in chennai
PHP Training in Chennai
PHP Course in Chennai

Vicky Ram said...

Thank you sharing this kind of noteworthy information. Nice Post.

smarthrsolution
Article submission sites

Aruna Ram said...

Great post, this is awesome and very creativity content. I really impressed. I want more updates.......
CCNA Course in Bangalore
CCNA Institute in Bangalore
CCNA Training Center in Bangalore
CCNA Training in Chennai Kodambakkam
CCNA Training in Chennai
CCNA Course in Chennai

Anbarasan14 said...

This was helpful and thanks for sharing this useful information. Kindly continue the work.

Spoken English Classes in Bangalore
Spoken English Class in Bangalore
Spoken English Training in Bangalore
Spoken English Course near me
Spoken English Classes in Chennai
Spoken English Class in Chennai
Spoken English in Chennai

dinesh said...

This information is impressive. I am inspired with your post writing style & how continuously you describe this topic. Eagerly waiting for your new blog keep doing more.
Android Training in Bangalore
Android Course in Bangalore
Android Training Institutes in Bangalore
Best Aws Training in Bangalore
hadoop classes in bangalore
hadoop institute in bangalore

sharmi chithra said...

It is very excellent blog and useful article thank you for sharing with us, keep posting.

Primavera Training in Chennai
Primavera Course in Chennai
Primavera Software Training in Chennai
Best Primavera Training in Chennai
Primavera p6 Training in Chennai
Primavera Coaching in Chennai
Primavera Course

gowthunan said...

Your very own commitment to getting the message throughout came to be rather powerful and have consistently enabled employees just like me to arrive at their desired goals.
iosh course in chennai

nanadhini chandran said...

Very interesting information that you have shared with us.i have personally thank you for sharing your ideas with us.
Salesforce Training in chennai
Salesforce Training in Anna Nagar
Salesforce Training Institutes in Vadapalani
Salesforce Training in T nagar

sharmi chithra said...

Nice post. By reading your blog, I get inspired .. Thank you for posting.

Informatica Training in Chennai
Informatica Training Center Chennai
Informatica Training Institute in Chennai
Best Informatica Training in Chennai
Informatica course in Chennai
Informatica Training center in Chennai
Informatica Training
Learn Informatica

vishnu said...

An amazing post. I like the way you have written the article. Keep up the good work.

Linux Course in Chennai
Linux Course
Linux Certification
Linux Training in Adyar
Linux Course in Velachery
Best Linux Training Institute in Tambaram

Dwarakesh babu said...

Hello! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a team of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community in the same niche. Your blog provided us useful information to work on. You have done an outstanding job.



AWS Training in Bangalore | Amazon Web Services Training in Bangalore

AWS Interview Questions And Answers

Learn Amazon Web Services Tutorial |AWS Tutorials For Beginners

Amazon Web Services Training in OMR , Chennai | Best AWS Training in OMR,Chennai


AWS Training in Chennai |Best Amazon Web Services Training in Chennai

Safety Professionals said...

I wish to show thanks to you just for bailing me out of this particular trouble. As a result of checking through the net and meeting techniques that were not productive, I thought my life was done.
nebosh course in chennai