Wednesday 6 July 2016

The Digital Humanities in Three Dimensions



This post is adapted from a talk I gave to the annual conference of the Australasian Association of Digital Humanities in Hobart on 21st June 2016.  It was a great conference with some great papers, leading to some great discussions.  This particular talk generated perhaps more heat than light, but  the main point seems important to me.



The Digital Humanities is a funny beast.  I tend to think of it as something of a pantomime horse – with criticism, distant reading and literary theory occupying the front end – all neighing and foot stamping at the MLA each year (and in the Los Angeles Review of Books) - while history, geography and library science are stuck in the rear – doing the hard work of creating new digital resources, and testing new tools.  Firmly at the back end of this arrangement, I spend much of my time hoping that the angry debates in the front don’t result in too many ructions behind.

But as a result of this weird portmanteau existence the Digital Humanities – its debates and its aspirations - has been largely about text.  As Matthew Kirchenbaum has noticed – much of it can be found in the English department.  Its origins are always located in the work of Father Busa and its greatest stars from Franco Moretti onwards, keep us focussed on the ‘distant reading’ of words. Indeed, the object of study for most Digital Humanists remains the inherited text of Western culture – now available for recalculation via Google Books, ECCO, EEBO, and Project Gutenberg. 

And because Digital Humanities is being led from areas of the academy that take as its object of study a canonical set of texts (however extensive and contested); we have been naturally led to use tools that privilege text analysis and to ignore methodologies that are focussed elsewhere.  The popular tools on the block are topic modelling of text, and network analysis based on the natural language processing, of text.  This is particularly true in North America where subjects such as geography do not have as strong an institutional presence as in Europe and much of the rest of the world, and where the spatial and sonic turns in the humanities feel less well established. 

This emphasis on text tends to make the Digital Humanities feel rather safer than it should. While the digital humanities is frequently cited for its disruptive potential - its ‘affordances’ – it is inherently conservative about what constitutes a legitimate subject, and has breathed new life into areas that forty years ago lready felt moribund.  The Enlightenment, and the papers of Newton, Austen, Bentham and Darwin – all dead writers of an elite stamp - have been revived and their ‘texts’ been made hyper-available.


In part, this is just about the rhythms of the academy.  The Digital Humanities arose just as post-modernism and second wave feminist criticism seemed to exit stage left, and with them, much of the imperative to critique the canon.  But it is also a result of underlying economic structures and the technologies of twentieth-century librarianship.  We very seldom acknowledge it, but the direction of our work is frequently determined and universally facilitated by the for-profit commercial information sector – by the likes of ProQuest, Google and Elsevier, Ancestry.com and Cengage Gale.  And they in turn are the product of a hundred-year history that has shaped what is available to all researchers in the humanities. 

If you want to know why, for example, The Times Digital Archive was the first major newspaper available online; if you want to know why early modern English books came next; if you want to know why Indian and African and South American literature is not available in the same way, it is down to selections made by these companies, and selections made, not last year, but a hundred years ago.

The current digital landscape is actually a reflection of an older underlying project, and an older technology.  Perhaps the biggest influence on what is available to researchers online – the biggest selection bias involved - is just a ghost of commercially produced, for profit, microfilm.  In other words, we have text because that is what people thought was important in 1906 or 1927, or 1935.  We tend to forget that microfilm was the great new technology of the twentieth century - and was itself part of an apparently radical disruptive intellectual project.  It is worthwhile remembering the details.


In 1906 Paul Otlet and Robert Goldschmidt proposed the livre microphotographique – library of microfilm – as a World Center Library of Juridical, Social and Cultural Documentation.  This was to be the ultimate universal library and knowledge machine – the library at Alexandria made new – and it was made possible by microfilm. 

Later perfected for commercial uses, by the late 1920s, microfilm was the methodology of choice used by the Library of Congress to film and republish some 3 million volumes from the British Library between 1927 and 1935; and in 1935, Kodak started filming The Times on a commercial basis.

And this pre-history of heritage material on the web is relevant for a simple reason.  It costs less than a penny per page to generate a digital image from a microfilm.  It is automated to the point that all you do is feed the reel into a machine wait.  By way of comparison, it costs around 15 pence per page to generate a similar image from a real book – even with modern automation, and three times that again capture a page of manuscript in an archive.  For many of the projects designed during the first decade of the web, it was cheaper to have material microfilmed first, as a first step in digitisation.

Seventeenth and eighteenth century books are available online precisely because the Library of Congress microfilmed them in in the 1920s; and The Times Digital Archive is available because Kodak microfilmed it over eighty years ago. Chinese and Arabic literature is not available in the same way because the Library of Congress and Kodak and their ilk decided it was not important. Pro-Quest, the multi-billion pound corporation that supplies half the material used by Digital Humanities scholars, started as University Microfilms International in 1938. 

In other words, what happened in the twentieth century – the aspiration to create a particular kind of universal library, and to commercialise world culture (and to a 1930s mind, this meant male and European culture) – essentially shapes what is now available on line. This is why most of the material we currently have is in black and white instead of colour.  And most importantly, it is why we have text; and in particular, canonical texts in English.

And if the Digital Humanities was really only the front end of that pantomime horse, this would not be that big a deal.  But the Digital Humanities is also the back end – all the people creating the infrastructure that defines world culture online.  If you ask an undergraduate (or most humanities professors) about their research practises, it rapidly becomes clear that hard copy wood pulp has been replaced by digital materials.  What we study is what we can find on line.  

In part, the selection bias driven by the role of microfilm and the textual bias this implies, just means that like the humanities in general, the digital sort is inherently, and institutionally, Western centric, elitist and racist.   Rich white people produced the text that the humanities tend to study and despite the heroic multi-generation effort that has sought to recover female voices; or projects seeking to give new voice to the poor – from below - this selective intellectual landscape remains.

In other words, the textual Digital Humanities offers a superficial and faux radicalism that effectively re-enforces the conservative character of much humanities research.  The Digital Humanities' problem in recruiting beyond white and privileged practitioners is not just down to the boorish cultures of code – rude male children being unwelcoming -  but a result of its object of study.

All of which is just by way of introducing the real subject of this post - that for us to actually grasp the ‘affordances’ that the digital makes possible we really need to change that ‘object of study’ and move beyond microfilmed cultures.   

And that when we add space and place, time and sound, to our analysis, and when we start from a hundred other places than the English department – from geography and archaeology, to quantitative biology and informatics – we can create something that is more compelling, more revealing and more powerful – and arguably more inclusive and democratic along the way.

By way of pursuing this idea, I want to go through a few of the different ways new tools and approaches create real opportunities to move beyond the analysis of ‘text’ to something more ambitious; and in the process attack that very real inherent bias – and inherent conservatism -  that the ‘textual’ humanities brings with it. 

The rain falls on every head – and I just want explore how we can move beyond the elite and the Western, the privileged and the male. 

In the humanities we think of digitisation of text,but in a dozen other fields, they are digitising different components of the physical world.  And when everything is digital – when all forms of stuff come to us down a single pipeline -  everything can be inter-related in new ways.  The web and the internet simply provides a context in which image, sound, video and text are brought onto a single page.

Consider for a moment the ‘Haptic Cow’ project from the Royal Veterinary College in London.  In this instance they have developed a full scale ‘haptic’ representation of a cow in labour, facing a difficult birth, which allows students to physically engage and experience the process of manipulating a calf in situ.  Imagine this technology applied to a more historical event, or process, or experience.  It suggests that the object of study can be different, and should include the haptic - the feel and heft of a thing in your hand.  This is being coded for millions of objects through 3d scanning; but we do not yet have an effective way of incorporating that 3d encoding into our reading of the past.  

And if we can ‘feel’ an object, it changes how we read the text that comes with it; or the experience that text encodes. The world would look and feel very different if we organised it around those objects – the inherited texts attached to them perhaps - but those objects’ origin and materiality forming the core of the meaning we seek to interrogate.  We can use the technology to think harder about the changing nature of work, or punishment, the ‘feel’ of oppression and luxury. Museums and collections - the catacombs of culture - are undoubtedly just as powerfully selective and controlling as the unseen hand of the publishers and archivists; but in stepping beyond text, we can hope to play the museums off against the text.


The same could be said of the aural - that weird world of sound on which we continually impose the order of language, music and meaning; but which is in fact a stream of sensations filtered through place and culture.  For people working in musicology there feels to be a ‘sonic turn’ in the humanities, but most of us have paid it little heed.

There are projects like the Virtual St Paul's Cross, which allows you to ‘hear’ John Donne’s sermons from the 1620s, from different vantage points around the yard.  Donne is a dead white man par excellence, but the project changes how we imagine the text and the event.  And again begins to navigate that normally unbridgeable space between text and the material world to help give us access to the experience of the beggar in the crowd, of women, children and the historically unvoiced. 

For myself, I want to understand a sermon heard in the precise church in which it was delivered; a political speech in the field, or parliamentary chamber; or an impassioned defence in the squalid courtroom in which it was enacted, or under an African judgement tree – with the weather and the smell thrown in.  And I want to hear it from the back of the hall, through the ears of a child or a servant.

This would help challenge us to think harder and differently about text that purport to represent speech, and text that sits between the mind and the page.  Recorded voice – even in the form of text – is inherently more quotidian, is inherently more likely to give us access to the 90 percent of the population whose voices are recorded, but whose 'text' is not.  Text recording speech is different to text produced by the elite power users of the technology of writing – who write directly from mind to page.  This at least shifts us a bit – from text, to voice.

Similarly, in the work of people such as Ian Gregory, we can see the beginnings of new ways of reading both the landscape, and the textual leavings of the dead in the landscape.   His projects on mapping the Lakeland poets; and mapping 19th century government reports, imply a new and different kind of reading.


What happens to a traveller's journal when it is mapped onto a landscape? What happens to a landscape painting when we can see both its reference landscape, and the studio in which it was completed?  What happens to even text, when it is understood to encode a basic geographical relationship?  How do we understand a conversation on a walk when we can map its phrases and exchanges against the earth’s surface?  And what forms of analysis can undertake when each journey, each neighbourhood, each street and room, are available to add to the text associated with them? 

The rain falls on every head.

All of which is to state the obvious.  There are lots of new technologies that change how we connect with historical evidence – whether that is text or something more interesting; and that we increasingly access it all via that single remarkable pipeline that is the online and the digital.   

But it strikes me that adding these new dimensions to the object of study allows us to do something important.  I have spent the last thirty-eight years working on a ‘history from below’ focused on the lives of eighteenth century London’s working people.  And what I want to suggest is that these new dimensions and methodologies actually make that project fundamentally more possible; and by extension makes the larger project of recovering the voices and experience of the voiceless dead, more possible.  When you add in the haptic, the mapped and the geographical, the aural and the 3D, what you actually end up with is a world in which non-elite – and non-western - people are newly available in a new way.  You also move from a kind of history as explanation, to history as empathy – across cultures and genders, across time and space.

Sound and space and place, are fundamentally more intellectually democratic than text.  90% our inherited canon is inherited from rich dead white men; and yet the thronging multitude who stood in St Paul’s Churchyard; the quotidian hoards who walked through the streets and listened to the ballad singers, experienced something that we can now recover.  The sound of judgement as experienced by the women and men who stood trial at the Old Bailey, and their voice of defiance, can be recovered.  And even the cold and wind of a weather that can now be captured day by day for a quarter of a millennium; can be added to the democratic possibilities new digital resources allow.  Add in the objects in the museums, the sounds of the ships, and their course through the oceans; the measurable experience of labour, and imprisonment, the joy of music and movement, the inherited landscapes, bearing all the marks of the toil of the voiceless dead, and you end up with something new.  The material world – in digital – gives us access to the rest of the world, and begins to create tools that speak to the 99% of the world’s population who, in 1700 or 1800 did not read or write, and did not leave easy traces for us to follow.  The Digital Humanities in Three Dimensions, challenges us and empowers us, to write a different, more inclusive, kind of history.

The rain falls on every head.   

80 comments:

  1. thanks for shared wonderful information of giving best information.its more useful and more helpful. great doing keep sharing
    PHP Training in Chennai Guindy

    ReplyDelete
  2. article makes an eloquent distinction between the Inner Game an the Outer Game as it applies to Leadership.
    INFORMATICA Training in Chennai Guindy

    ReplyDelete

  3. Thank you for taking the time to provide us with your valuable information. We strive to provide our candidates with excellent care and we take your comments to heart.As always, we appreciate your confidence and trust in us.


    VMware Training in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  4. I do agree with all the ideas you have presented in your post. They’re really convincing and will certainly work. Still, the posts are very short for newbies. Could you please extend them a little from next time?..Keep this great work..

    Web development company in Chennai


    ReplyDelete
  5. Great Article… I love to read your articles because your writing style is too good, its is very very helpful for all of us and I never get bored while reading your article because, they are becomes a

    more and more interesting from the starting lines until the end.

    digital marketing company in chennai
    seo company in chennai

    ReplyDelete

  6. Top 10 attractive natural tourist place in
    Bangladesh.click below the link.
    http://adf.ly/1feChP

    ReplyDelete

  7. First of all i am saying that i like your post very much.I am really impressed by the way in which you presented the content and also the structure of the post. Hope you can gave us more posts like this and i really appreciate your hardwork.

    Teddy Day 2017
    Happy New Year 2018 GIF
    valentine week date 2019
    symbols status whatsapp
    Good Night Messages
    Birthday Wishes for Father
    Happy New Year 2017 Greetings

    ReplyDelete
  8. Brain Fitness Food Supplements for your mind are helping peoples.It give real preparing benefits. And Benefits are Enhanced MEMORY, FOCUS,Decreased FATIGUE,reduce STRESS RESPONSE, The best brain supplements are Citicoline,Curcumin,Magnesium Threonate,Acetyl L-Carnitine.Visit on www.shoplie.com/citicoline/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Very nice post here and thanks for latest smartphone applications it .I always like and such a super colors of phone for these post.Excellent and very cool idea and great models and different kinds of the more information's.

    web designing training in chennai

    ReplyDelete


  10. Thanks for posting useful information.You have provided an nice article, Thank you very much for this one. And i hope this will be useful for many people.. and i am waiting for your next post keep on updating these kinds of knowledgeable things...Really it was an awesome article...very interesting to read..please sharing like this information......
    Web Design Development Company
    Mobile App Development Company

    ReplyDelete

  11. I am expecting more interesting topics from you. And this was nice content and definitely it will be useful for many people.
    Fitness SMS
    Salon SMS
    Investor Relation SMS

    ReplyDelete
  12. your article is more useful and informative.. thanks to share this... keep rocking..

    Software Testing Training in chennai |
    Software Testing Course in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  13. I feel a lot more people need to read this, very good info! …
    Assignment Help Sydney

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thank you for another great article. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such a perfect way of presentation. Child homeopathy clinic in Jaipur

    ReplyDelete
  15. Awesome Post!
    Check out Happy Diwali Greetings 2017-2018
    Also download latest movie LOGAN 2017 DUAL AUDIO 720P BLURAY HINDI
    Also Read trending Story Expectations vs reality
    Also Check out Latest vacancy of Government Job Kar Tet Recruitment 2017

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thank you for taking the time to provide us with your valuable information. We strive to provide our candidates with excellent care and we take your comments to heart.As always, we appreciate your confidence and trust in us.
    PHP Training Institute in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  17. I am expecting more interesting topics from you. And this was nice content and definitely it will be useful for many people.

    Java Training Institute in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  18. Pretty article! I found some useful information in your blog, it was awesome to read, thanks for sharing this great content to my vision, keep sharing..
    snapho

    ReplyDelete
  19. This is a great test blog! I personally love it and find that it

    happy valentines day 2018 wishes

    ReplyDelete
  20. Very nice Article Digital marketing is the process of promoting brands or products using electronic media mainly on internet.Digital marketing includes SEO,SEM,SMO,SMM etc.
    Digital Marketing

    ReplyDelete
  21. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete

  22. NICE for giving a chance to share ideas for your comuty i really thanks for that great post.
    Best Ice Fishing Gloves Best Ice Fishing Gloves Best Ice Fishing Gloves

    ReplyDelete
  23. I really love this blog. I am running Website Designing Company in Delhi and Website Designing Company in Faridabad . That blog will help me for promote my website.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Great and valuable information put in this blog, thank you so much for sharing this information with us. Visit OGEN Infosystem for responsive web design and SEO Service.
    SEO Service in Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  25. Very Impressive post, really this is very informative post. While the world is turning acidic, alkaline water is the new food solution trend hitting all over the world.Buy only the best Alkaline water machine with 100% of effectiveness from the leading Water ionizer india. A powerful machine that helps to fight against osteoporosis and Cancer from acidic water.

    For More Information Visit Us:
    Water ionizer machine
    Alkaline water machine india
    alkaline water ionizer machine in india
    Alkaline water machine
    Water ionizer India

    ReplyDelete
  26. Thank for sharing informative post. In the era of various emergences of air pollutant diseases like COPD, Stroke, lung cancer and many more, an Air Purifier in your home is a necessary appliance. BreatheFresh is best air purifier in india.

    air purifiers
    air purifier india
    best air purifier india

    ReplyDelete
  27. Thanks for this great Ideas regarding this topic. We can choose friends web designer company (https://friendswebdesigner.blogspot.com) to create a best business website to grow your profits. which helps to grow your bussiness online.

    Affordable website designing company in delhi

    Website Designing Company

    ReplyDelete
  28. What a fantastic post! This is so chock full of useful information. I can't wait to dig deep and start utilizing the information you have given me. assignment maker

    ReplyDelete
  29. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Wonderful bloggers like yourself who would positively reply encouraged me to be more open and engaging in commenting.So know it's helpful.
    Office interior designers in chennai
    living room interior designers in chennai
    False ceiling interiors designers in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  31. Nice post If you are an Uber driver then you might be searching for the
    best dash cam for uber .The dash cam is the most important part of the car. It is widely used by many drivers throughout the world.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Hello Guys I am Saisha Chaddha From Town Call Girl. If You Are Looking For a Beautiful looking in Town Then Contact me. I am Hot and Sexy Looking Charming and Beautiful Call Girl in Town. I m a very Nice Companion in and of the bed.
    Call Girls in Aravalli !!
    Call Girls in Banaskantha !!
    Call Girls in Mehsana !!
    Call Girls in Patan !!
    Call Girls in Sabarkantha !!
    Call Girls in Saurashtra Kutch !!
    Call Girls in Botad !!
    Call Girls in Devbhoomi Dwarka !!
    Call Girls in Gir Somnath !!
    Call Girls in Porbandar !!

    ReplyDelete
  33. Great information, thanks for sharing this excellent blog with us. Ogen Infosystem is one of the leading Website Designing Company in Bangalore. Visit our website for more information.
    Website Design Company in Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  34. ●▬▬▬▬PART TIME JOBS▬▬▬▬▬●

    I am making $165 an hour working from home. i was greatly surprised at the same time as my neighbour advised me she changed into averaging $ninety five however I see the way it works now. I experience masses freedom now that i'm my non-public boss. that is what I do......
    ↓↓↓↓COPY THIS SITE↓↓↓↓

    HERE►►►►►►www.besttrends7.com

    ReplyDelete
  35. Whether you are just a start-up or have an established business, our proficient team is capable of providing you best mobile app development services in India.

    Visit More About: Mobile App Development Services | Top Mobile App Development Company

    ReplyDelete
  36. Hey ,

    Great Job . You Know what ?

    I read a lot of blog posts and I never heard of such a topic. I love the subject you have done about bloggers. Very simple. I am also writing a blog related to the malta work permit. You can also see this.

    ReplyDelete
  37. What a fantastic post! This is so chock full of useful information I can't wait to dig deep and start utilizing the resources you have given me. your exuberance is refreshing

    you've outdone yourself this time

    This is probably the best, most concise step-by-step guide I've ever seen on how to build a successful blog. i am also writing blog about the kindly review it online english speaking classes for kids.

    ReplyDelete
  38. What an awesome post! This is so crammed with helpful data I can hardly wait to burrow profound and begin using the assets you have given me. your abundance is invigorating

    you've done something extraordinary for yourself this time

    This is presumably the awesome, brief bit by bit direct I've at any point seen on the most proficient method to construct a fruitful blog. I'm likewise composing blog about the kindly audit it. french language institute in delhi .

    ReplyDelete
  39. You will definitely have to contact us if you cannot start the discussion online or create a post on the discussion board. Ask write my discussion board post please! Gold-essays.com has gained a solid reputation and it is now viewed as one of the most prolific and competitive writing companies online.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Hi guys, the name is Ashika Soni, a beautiful and genuine model who is an independent call girl too. A 21-year-old woman looking for some short time sex that will make you delirious with pleasure.
    Call girls
    Call girl
    Female
    Call girls for party
    Hotel call girls
    Model
    Incall girls
    Outcall girls
    Escort service
    Female call girls service
    Erotic massage
    Call girls number
    Call girl number

    ReplyDelete
  41. Great Blog and visit to webgross is the familiar name on contented clients lips concerning perfect Website Development Services Delhi. After extensive research on your brand, we develop your website that proves as a voice to your brand with easy navigation and a user-friendly experience. Our services are in it for the long haul Content writing services Delhi.

    ReplyDelete

  42. Get the best deals on Huawei Switches and find everything you'll need to improve your home office setup at Cloud Infotech.

    ReplyDelete
  43. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  44. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Thanks for sharing this post found this post and liked it very much but did it.
    If you want to know more related to this article then visit our website
    Visit website =Best IELTS Coaching East Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  46. Thanks for sharing this post found this post and liked it very much but did it.
    If you want to know more related to this article then visit our website
    Visit website =Computer Classes in East Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  47. Thanks for sharing. I found a lot of interesting information here. A really good post, very thankful and hopeful that you will write many more posts like this one.
    digital marketing company in jaipur

    digital marketing packages

    seo company in Noida

    Digital Marketing Company in Delhi

    website designing company in Delhi NCR

    ReplyDelete
  48. Know About Knock Knee Surgery Cost in India. Best Source For Connecting With Orthopaedic And Joint Replacement Surgeon And Planning Budget Friendly Treatment. Dr. Dk Dass Is Trusted By Thousands Of Patients Globally.

    ReplyDelete
  49. As a complement, The presents very useful information gathered. satta matka Thanks for sharing

    ReplyDelete
  50. Hi,
    I just fall in love with your informative articles and I want more from you. Acetyl L-carnitine (ALCAR) is a supplement commonly utilized for its physical and mental health benefits. It is a type of amino acid L-carnitine which plays an important role in the metabolism of energy within the body. Here are a few important points concerning acetyl L-carnitine. Energy Metabolism acetyl l carnitine assists in transporting fat acids to mitochondria that are the powerhouses of cells. There, they are transformed into energy usable. This process is crucial for muscles and the brain because they depend on fatty acids to fuel production.

    ReplyDelete
  51. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  52. Bravo to this exceptional blog! It's a wellspring of knowledge and inspiration, consistently delivering valuable insights and engaging content. Keep up the great work! website designing company in delhi

    ReplyDelete
  53. Medibrandox specializes in providing top-notch dentist website design services. Our expert team is dedicated to creating customized websites that cater specifically to the needs of dental professionals. Elevate your online presence and connect with patients effectively with our visually captivating and user-friendly dentist website design solutions. Choose Medibrandox for a distinctive and impactful online presence for dentists.





    ReplyDelete
  54. Discover top-quality dental implants in Delhi at Thedentalroots. Our expert team of dentists specializes in restoring your smile and oral health with state-of-the-art implant technology. Experience personalized care, precision, and lasting results. Regain your confidence and enjoy a natural-looking, functional smile with our dental implant services in Delhi. Your journey to a healthier, more beautiful smile starts here.




    ReplyDelete
  55. Samarpan Recovery is a prominent rehab centres in mumbai. We are committed to helping individuals on their journey to recovery from addiction and substance abuse. With a dedicated team and modern facilities, we offer a supportive and caring environment for those seeking a healthier, substance-free life. Samarpan Recovery is your trusted partner for rehabilitation and healing in Mumbai.




    ReplyDelete
  56. Freelancers Hub Canada is a results-driven digital marketing agency that delivers innovative solutions tailored to your unique business needs. Our expert team combines diverse skills and knowledge to ensure your marketing campaigns achieve measurable success and propel your business forward.

    ReplyDelete
  57. VERY INFORMATIONAL THINGS YOU TELL TO PUBLIC VERY GOOD WORK,KEEP IT UP.
    We also believe sharing good content where we help organizations grow with help of digital marketing:
    website designing company in Ghaziabad

    ReplyDelete
  58. Very great efforts your showing in this blog,We also believe sharing good content where we help organizations grow with help of digital marketing:
    website designing company in Vasundhara

    ReplyDelete
  59. very nice work, well done.We also believe sharing good content where we help organizations grow with help of digital marketing:
    website designing company in Indirapuram

    ReplyDelete
  60. WELL DONE,We also believe sharing good content where we help organizations grow with help of digital marketing:
    website developer in Ghaziabad
    website designer in Ghaziabad

    ReplyDelete
  61. With each article, your site skillfully combines perceptive viewpoints with captivating information to provide readers with an enjoyable and thought-provoking experience.
    English to Hindi Dictionary Online

    ReplyDelete
  62. The Canadian vitamin shop is a great resource that I just learned about. I use top-notch vitamins to help me achieve my fitness objectives and recuperate faster since I lead an active lifestyle. Among the many sports nutrition options available at the Canadian Vitamin Shop are amino acid powders, pre-workout mixes, and protein powders. Thanks to these vitamins, I've seen a marked improvement in my health, and I will most certainly be a returning client.

    ReplyDelete
  63. Don't miss out on the opportunity to upgrade your skills and advance your career in industrial automation. Enroll in the PLC SCADA Course in Noida at APTRON Solutions today and take the first step towards a rewarding career in this thriving field. Contact us now to learn more about course schedules, fees, and enrollment procedures. Unlock your potential with APTRON Solutions – your gateway to success in PLC SCADA!

    ReplyDelete
  64. This article is very informative! I was wondering if you could elaborate on online branding and digital marketing course in krishnagiri

    ReplyDelete